| Area (mi^2) | State/Province | Lake | Island | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 209 | Michigan | Superior | Isle Royale | 92%
|
| 1,068 | Ontario | Huron | Manitoulin Island | 67%
|
| 31 | Ontario | Huron | Barrie Island | 33%
|
| 56 | Michigan | Michigan | Beaver Island | 33%
|
| 35 | Michigan | Huron | Bois Blanc Island | 33%
|
| 67.6 | Ontario | Huron | Cockburn Island | 33%
|
| 134 | Michigan | Huron | Drummond Island | 33%
|
| 71 | Ontario | Superior | Michipicoten Island | 33%
|
| 141 | Ontario | Huron | St. Joseph Island | 33%
|
| 50 | Michigan | Huron | Sugar Island | 33%
|
| 48 | Ontario | Ontario | Wolfe Island | 33%
|
| 28 | Ontario | Superior | Simpson Island | 25%
|
| 106 | Ontario | Superior | St. Ignace Island | 25%
|
| 36 | Ontario | Huron | Great La Cloche Island | 8%
|
| 30 | Ontario | Huron | Parry Island | 8%
|