| Appearences | Club | Nation | Years Active | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 657 | Juventus | Italy | 1995-2021 | Gianluigi Buffon | 95%
|
| 647 | AC Milan | Italy | 1984-2009 | Paolo Maldini | 95%
|
| 619 | AS Roma | Italy | 1992-2017 | Francesco Totti | 93%
|
| 615 | Inter Milan | Argentina | 1995-2014 | Javier Zanetti | 86%
|
| 419 | Juventus | Italy | 2004- | Giorgio Chiellini | 84%
|
| 478 | Juventus | Italy | 1993-2012 | Alessandro Del Piero | 81%
|
| 459 | AS Roma | Italy | 2001-2019 | Daniele De Rossi | 77%
|
| 470 | AC Milan | Italy | 1977-1997 | Franco Baresi | 74%
|
| 532 | Inter Milan | Slovenia | 2005- | Samir Handanovic | 72%
|
| 489 | Genoa | North Macedonia | 2001- | Gordan Pandev | 70%
|
| 493 | AC Milan | Italy | 1994-2015 | Andrea Pirlo | 63%
|
| 515 | Sampdoria | Italy | 1999- | Fabio Quagliarella | 58%
|
| 570 | Juventus | Italy | 1961-1983 | Dino Zoff | 53%
|
| 541 | Sampdoria | Italy | 1981-2000 | Roberto Mancini | 49%
|
| 420 | Sassuolo | Italy | 2008- | Andrea Consigli | 35%
|
| 592 | Bologna | Italy | 1987-2007 | Gianluca Pagliuca | 19%
|