| Last name | # | Relationship | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Atwood | #5 | Adopted son of #1 and #2 | Ryan | 97%
|
| Cohen | #3 | Son of #1 and #2 | Seth | 97%
|
| Cohen | #1 | Husband of #2 | Sandy | 93%
|
| Roberts | #13 | Long-time girlfriend of #3 | Summer | 93%
|
| Cooper | #9 | Long-time girlfriend of #5 | Marissa | 90%
|
| Cohen | #2 | Wife of #1 | Kirsten | 85%
|
| Cooper | #10 | Mother of #9 and #12 | Julie | 80%
|
| Others | #19 | Boyfriend of #9 and #10 | Luke | 71%
|
| Cooper | #11 | Father of #9 and #12 | Jimmy | 69%
|
| Nichol | #15 | Father of #2 | Caleb | 66%
|
| Townsend | #17 | Girlfriend of #5 | Taylor | 63%
|
| Others | #21 | Girlfriend of #3 | Anna | 56%
|
| Atwood | #6 | Brother of #5 | Trey | 54%
|
| Cooper | #12 | Sister of #9 | Kaitlin | 51%
|
| Others | #25 | Girlfriend of #3 and #9 | Alex | 42%
|
| Nichol | #16 | Sister of #2 | Hailey | 42%
|
| Others | #20 | Boyfriend of #13 | Zach | 39%
|
| Others | #23 | Daughter of #15 | Lindsay | 36%
|
| Others | #24 | Girlfriend of #5 | Theresa | 34%
|
| Atwood | #8 | Father of #5 and #6 | Frank | 31%
|
| Roberts | #14 | Father of #13 | Neil | 27%
|
| Atwood | #7 | Mother of #5 and #6 | Dawn | 20%
|
| Cohen | #4 | Mother of #1 | Sophie | 19%
|
| Others | #26 | Boyfriend of #12 | Johnny | 17%
|
| Townsend | #18 | Mother of #17 | Veronica | 14%
|
| Others | #22 | Boyfriend of #9 | Kevin | 10%
|