| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| The Supreme | Fiona Goode | 74%
|
| Everyone's favourite sociopath | Tate Langdon | 69%
|
| Head of the Freakshow | Elsa Mars | 64%
|
| Runs Briarcliff | Sister Jude | 64%
|
| A journalist who gets too involved | Lana Winters | 62%
|
| "Swamp Witch" | Misty Day | 60%
|
| Young girl who kills herself | Violet Harmon | 60%
|
| Blamed for murders he did not commit | Kit Walker | 59%
|
| Has "Lobster hands" | Jimmy Darling | 55%
|
| Cheated with his student | Ben Harmon | 52%
|
| Hollywood diva with telekinesis | Madison Montgomery | 52%
|
| A very unfortunate mother | Constance Langdon | 51%
|
| Daughter of the Supreme | Cordelia Foxx | 46%
|
| Quirky Witch- burnt twice | Myrtle Snow | 46%
|
| Younger Nun who appears in both Asylum and Freakshow | Sister Mary Eunice | 46%
|
| Gives birth to the antichrist | Vivien Harmon | 44%
|
| Spoilt rich kid who has an issue with animals | Dandy Mott | 42%
|
| Wife of the Murder House's first owner | Nora Montgomery | 40%
|
| The Maid with two appearances | Moira O'Hara | 37%
|
| Talented witch with "Black Widow" powers | Zoe Benson | 31%
|
| Can Speak to the dead | Billie Dean Howard | 29%
|
| Nazi doctor | Arthur Arden | 27%
|
| Rich mother of a psychopath | Gloria Mott | 27%
|
| An attractive college student | Kyle Spencer | 26%
|
| Twins who share too much | Bette and Dot Tattler | 24%
|
| Appears by the dying in Asylum | Angel of Death | 19%
|
| Psychopathic psychiatrist | Oliver Thredson | 18%
|
| Cheating boyfriend of the above | Patrick | 18%
|
| Obsessed with which type of apples to use for Halloween | Chad Warwick | 14%
|
| Falls in love with Kit- axe murderess | Grace Bertrand | 12%
|