| # | Pos. | Player | Team | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 | 1B | Albert Pujols | St. Louis Cardinals | 100%
|
| 34 | DH | David Ortiz | Boston Red Sox | 100%
|
| 29 | 3B | Adrian Beltre | Seattle Mariners | 67%
|
| 40 | P | Bartolo Colon | Los Angeles Angels | 67%
|
| 9 | SS | Jose Reyes | New York Mets | 67%
|
| 18 | OF | Moises Alou | San Francisco Giants | 67%
|
| 12 | 2B | Alfonso Soriano | Washington Nationals | 33%
|
| 51 | P | Eude Brito | Philadelphia Phillies | 33%
|
| 56 | P | Fernando Rodney | Detroit Tigers | 33%
|
| 15 | C | Juan Brito | Free Agent | 33%
|
| 10 | SS | Miguel Tejada | Baltimore Orioles | 33%
|
| 55 | P | Odalis Perez | Los Angeles Dodgers | 33%
|
| 2 | 2B | Placido Polanco | Detroit Tigers | 33%
|
| 27 | OF | Vladimir Guerrero | Los Angeles Angels | 33%
|
| 22 | C | Alberto Castillo | Free Agent | 0%
|
| 38 | P | Damaso Marte | Pittsburgh Pirates | 0%
|
| 35 | P | Daniel Cabrera | Baltimore Orioles | 0%
|
| 52 | P | Duaner Sanchez | New York Mets | 0%
|
| 41 | P | Francisco Liriano | Minnesota Twins | 0%
|
| 33 | P | Jorge Sosa | Atlanta Braves | 0%
|
| 19 | OF | Juan Encarnacion | St. Louis Cardinals | 0%
|
| 53 | P | Julian Tavarez | Boston Red Sox | 0%
|
| 8 | OF | Luis Polonia | Águilas Cibaeñas | 0%
|
| Mng | Manny Acta | 0%
| ||
| 43 | P | Miguel Batista | Arizona Diamondbacks | 0%
|
| 7 | 3B | Pedro Feliz | San Francisco Giants | 0%
|
| 47 | P | Robinson Tejeda | Texas Rangers | 0%
|
| 20 | 2B | Ronnie Belliard | Cleveland Indians | 0%
|
| 31 | C | Ronny Paulino | Pittsburgh Pirates | 0%
|
| 15 | P | Salomon Torres | Pittsburgh Pirates | 0%
|
| 4 | OF | Willy Taveras | Houston Astros | 0%
|
| 26 | OF | Wily Mo Pena | Boston Red Sox | 0%
|