| Player | # | Retired | Team | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Babe Ruth | 714 | 1935 | NYY | 95%
|
| Barry Bonds | 762 | 2007 | SFG | 95%
|
| Barry Bonds | 514 | 2007 | SFG | 95%
|
| Henry Aaron | 3771 | 1976 | ATL | 95%
|
| Henry Aaron | 755 | 1976 | ATL | 95%
|
| Albert Pujols | 3384 | 2022 | STL | 90%
|
| Albert Pujols | 703 | 2022 | STL | 90%
|
| Alex Rodriguez | 3115 | 2016 | NYY | 90%
|
| Alex Rodriguez | 696 | 2016 | NYY | 90%
|
| Cy Young | 511 | 1911 | CLV | 90%
|
| Mariano Rivera | 652 | 2013 | NYY | 90%
|
| Nolan Ryan | 324 | 1993 | HOU | 90%
|
| Nolan Ryan | 5714 | 1993 | HOU | 90%
|
| Randy Johnson | 303 | 2009 | SEA | 90%
|
| Randy Johnson | 4875 | 2009 | SEA | 90%
|
| Rickey Henderson | 3055 | 2003 | OAK | 90%
|
| Rickey Henderson | 1406 | 2003 | OAK | 90%
|
| Walter Johnson | 417 | 1927 | WSH | 90%
|
| Walter Johnson | 3509 | 1922 | WSH | 90%
|
| David Ortiz | 541 | 2016 | BOS | 85%
|
| Derek Jeter | 3465 | 2014 | NYY | 85%
|
| Francisco Rodríguez | 437 | 2017 | LAA | 85%
|
| Greg Maddux | 355 | 2008 | ATL | 85%
|
| Greg Maddux | 3371 | 2008 | ATL | 85%
|
| Ken Griffey Jr. | 630 | 2010 | SEA | 85%
|
| Mark McGwire | 583 | 2001 | OAK | 85%
|
| Pedro Martinez | 3154 | 2009 | BOS | 85%
|
| Pete Rose | 4256 | 1986 | CIN | 85%
|
| Roger Clemens | 354 | 2007 | BOS | 85%
|
| Roger Clemens | 4672 | 2007 | BOS | 85%
|
| Ty Cobb | 4189 | 1928 | DET | 85%
|
| Ty Cobb | 897 | 1928 | DET | 85%
|
| Cal Ripken Jr. | 3184 | 2001 | BAL | 80%
|
| Ichiro Suzuki | 3089 | 2019 | SEA | 80%
|
| Ichiro Suzuki | 509 | 2019 | SEA | 80%
|
| Mickey Mantle | 536 | 1968 | NYY | 80%
|
| Miguel Cabrera | 3174 | 2023 | DET | 80%
|
| Miguel Cabrera | 511 | 2023 | DET | 80%
|
| Mike Schmidt | 548 | 1989 | PHI | 80%
|
| Roberto Clemente | 3000 | 1972 | PIT | 80%
|
| Sammy Sosa | 609 | 2007 | CHC | 80%
|
| Ted Williams | 521 | 1960 | BOS | 80%
|
| Willie Mays | 3293 | 1973 | NYG | 80%
|
| Willie Mays | 660 | 1973 | NYG | 80%
|
| Billy Wagner | 422 | 2010 | HOU | 75%
|
| Honus Wagner | 3420 | 1917 | PIT | 75%
|
| Honus Wagner | 723 | 1917 | PIT | 75%
|
| Jim Thome | 612 | 2012 | CLE | 75%
|
| Lee Smith | 478 | 1997 | CHC | 75%
|
| Ozzie Smith | 580 | 1996 | STL | 75%
|
| Stan Musial | 3630 | 1963 | STL | 75%
|
| Eddie Mathews | 512 | 1968 | ATL | 70%
|
| George Brett | 3154 | 1993 | KCR | 70%
|
| John Smoltz | 3084 | 2009 | ATL | 70%
|
| Justin Verlander | 3416 | Active | SFG | 70%
|
| Manny Ramirez | 555 | 2011 | BOS | 70%
|
| Max Scherzer | 3407 | Active | TOR | 70%
|
| Paul Molitor | 3319 | 1998 | MIL | 70%
|
| Paul Molitor | 504 | 1998 | MIL | 70%
|
| Reggie Jackson | 563 | 1987 | OAK | 70%
|
| Robin Yount | 3142 | 1993 | MIL | 70%
|
| Tony Gwynn | 3141 | 2001 | SDP | 70%
|
| Wade Boggs | 3010 | 1999 | BOS | 70%
|
| Bob Gibson | 3117 | 1975 | STL | 65%
|
| Christy Mathewson | 373 | 1916 | NYG | 65%
|
| Craig Biggio | 3060 | 2007 | HOU | 65%
|
| Frank Robinson | 586 | 1976 | CIN | 65%
|
| Frank Thomas | 521 | 2008 | CHW | 65%
|
| Harmon Killebrew | 573 | 1975 | MIN | 65%
|
| Lou Brock | 3023 | 1979 | STL | 65%
|
| Lou Brock | 938 | 1979 | STL | 65%
|
| Phil Niekro | 318 | 1987 | ATL | 65%
|
| Phil Niekro | 3342 | 1987 | ATL | 65%
|
| Tom Seaver | 311 | 1986 | NYM | 65%
|
| Tom Seaver | 3640 | 1986 | NYM | 65%
|
| Trevor Hoffman | 601 | 2010 | SDP | 65%
|
| Carl Yastrzemski | 3419 | 1983 | BOS | 60%
|
| CC Sabathia | 3093 | 2019 | NYY | 60%
|
| Dennis Eckersley | 390 | 1998 | OAK | 60%
|
| Ernie Banks | 512 | 1971 | CHC | 60%
|
| Rafael Palmeiro | 3020 | 2005 | TEX | 60%
|
| Rafael Palmeiro | 569 | 2005 | TEX | 60%
|
| Tim Raines | 808 | 2002 | MON | 60%
|
| Tom Glavine | 305 | 2008 | ATL | 60%
|
| Warren Spahn | 363 | 1965 | BSN | 60%
|
| Adrian Beltré | 3166 | 2018 | TEX | 55%
|
| Dave Winfield | 3110 | 1995 | NYY | 55%
|
| Eddie Murray | 3255 | 1997 | BAL | 55%
|
| Eddie Murray | 504 | 1997 | BAL | 55%
|
| Gaylord Perry | 314 | 1983 | SFG | 55%
|
| Gaylord Perry | 3534 | 1983 | SFG | 55%
|
| Rich Gossage | 310 | 1994 | NYY | 55%
|
| Rollie Fingers | 341 | 1985 | OAK | 55%
|
| Steve Carlton | 329 | 1988 | PHI | 55%
|
| Steve Carlton | 4136 | 1988 | PHI | 55%
|
| Willie McCovey | 521 | 1980 | SFG | 55%
|
| Aroldis Chapman | 335 | Active | BOS | 50%
|
| Bert Blyleven | 3701 | 1992 | MIN | 50%
|
| Cap Anson | 3435 | 1897 | CHC | 50%
|
| Craig Kimbrel | 440 | Active | BAL | 50%
|
| Jimmie Foxx | 534 | 1945 | PHA | 50%
|
| Nap Lajoie | 3243 | 1916 | CLE | 50%
|
| Tris Speaker | 3514 | 1928 | CLE | 50%
|
| Vince Coleman | 752 | 1997 | STL | 50%
|
| Willie Wilson | 668 | 1994 | KCR | 50%
|
| Al Kaline | 3007 | 1974 | DET | 45%
|
| Don Sutton | 324 | 1988 | LAD | 45%
|
| Don Sutton | 3574 | 1988 | LAD | 45%
|
| Doug Jones | 303 | 2000 | CLE | 45%
|
| Fergie Jenkins | 3192 | 1983 | CHC | 45%
|
| Kenley Jansen | 447 | Active | LAA | 45%
|
| Mel Ott | 511 | 1947 | NYG | 45%
|
| Rod Carew | 3053 | 1985 | MIN | 45%
|
| Todd Jones | 319 | 2008 | DET | 45%
|
| Billy Hamilton | 914 | 1901 | PHI | 40%
|
| Eddie Collins | 3315 | 1930 | PHA | 40%
|
| Eddie Collins | 741 | 1930 | PHA | 40%
|
| Grover Alexander | 373 | 1930 | CHC | 40%
|
| Lefty Grove | 300 | 1941 | PHA | 40%
|
| Curt Schilling | 3116 | 2007 | PHI | 35%
|
| Davey Lopes | 557 | 1987 | LAD | 35%
|
| John Franco | 424 | 2005 | NYM | 35%
|
| José Reyes | 517 | 2018 | NYM | 35%
|
| Juan Pierre | 614 | 2013 | FLA | 35%
|
| Kenny Lofton | 622 | 2007 | CLE | 35%
|
| Maury Wills | 586 | 1972 | LAD | 35%
|
| Paul Waner | 3152 | 1945 | PIT | 35%
|
| Roberto Hernández | 326 | 2007 | CHW | 35%
|
| Tom Brown | 658 | 1898 | WHS | 35%
|
| Bruce Sutter | 300 | 1988 | CHC | 30%
|
| Early Wynn | 300 | 1963 | CLE | 30%
|
| Gary Sheffield | 509 | 2009 | FLA | 30%
|
| George Davis | 619 | 1909 | NYG | 30%
|
| Joe Morgan | 689 | 1984 | HOU | 30%
|
| Joe Nathan | 377 | 2016 | MIN | 30%
|
| Bert Campaneris | 549 | 1983 | OAK | 25%
|
| César Cedeño | 550 | 1986 | HOU | 25%
|
| Fernando Rodney | 327 | 2019 | DET | 25%
|
| Huston Street | 324 | 2017 | OAK | 25%
|
| Jason Isringhausen | 300 | 2012 | STL | 25%
|
| Jeff Reardon | 367 | 1994 | MON | 25%
|
| Kid Nichols | 362 | 1906 | BSN | 25%
|
| Luis Aparicio | 506 | 1973 | CHW | 25%
|
| Randy Myers | 347 | 1999 | NYM | 25%
|
| Robb Nen | 314 | 2004 | SFG | 25%
|
| Tom Henke | 311 | 1995 | TOR | 25%
|
| Troy Percival | 358 | 2009 | ANA | 25%
|
| Eddie Plank | 326 | 1917 | PHA | 20%
|
| Fred Clarke | 509 | 1915 | PIT | 20%
|
| Jonathan Papelbon | 368 | 2016 | BOS | 20%
|
| José Mesa | 321 | 2007 | CLE | 20%
|
| Old Hoss Radbourn | 310 | 1891 | PRO | 20%
|
| Otis Nixon | 620 | 1999 | ATL | 20%
|
| Rick Aguilera | 318 | 2000 | MIN | 20%
|
| Bid McPhee | 568 | 1899 | CIN | 15%
|
| Brett Butler | 558 | 1997 | LAD | 15%
|
| Francisco Cordero | 329 | 2012 | TEX | 15%
|
| Jeff Montgomery | 304 | 1999 | KCR | 15%
|
| John Wetteland | 330 | 2000 | TEX | 15%
|
| Hugh Duffy | 574 | 1906 | BSN | 10%
|
| John Clarkson | 328 | 1894 | BSN | 10%
|
| Max Carey | 738 | 1929 | PIT | 10%
|
| Mickey Welch | 307 | 1892 | NYG | 10%
|
| Pud Galvin | 365 | 1892 | BUF | 10%
|
| Tim Keefe | 342 | 1893 | NYG | 10%
|
| Arlie Latham | 742 | 1909 | STL | 5%
|
| Bill Dahlen | 548 | 1911 | CHC | 5%
|
| Billy Hoy | 596 | 1902 | CIN | 5%
|
| George Van Haltren | 583 | 1903 | NYG | 5%
|
| Harry Stovey | 509 | 1893 | PHA | 5%
|
| Herman Long | 537 | 1904 | BSN | 5%
|
| Jack Doyle | 518 | 1905 | NYG | 5%
|
| John Ward | 540 | 1894 | NYG | 5%
|
| Patsy Donovan | 518 | 1907 | PIT | 5%
|