| WAR | Years | Player | Pos. | Awards | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 142.7 | 1954 - 1974 | Henry Aaron | RF | 3x GG, 1957 MVP | 100%
|
| 85.3 | 1993 - 2012 | Chipper Jones | 3B | 2x SS, 1999 MVP | 98%
|
| 61.0 | 1996 - 2007 | Andruw Jones | CF | 10x GG, SS | 96%
|
| 67.3 | 1993 - 2003 | Greg Maddux | P | 10x GG, 1993 1994 1995 Cy Young | 96%
|
| 69.5 | 1988 - 2008 | John Smoltz | P | SS, 1996 Cy Young | 96%
|
| 63.6 | 1987 - 2002, 2008 | Tom Glavine | P | 4x SS 1991 1998 Cy Young | 96%
|
| 43.0 | 2010 - 2021 | Freddie Freeman | 1B | GG, 3x SS, 2020 MVP | 87%
|
| 93.9 | 1952 - 1966 | Eddie Mathews | 3B | 81%
| |
| 88.5 | 1966 - 1983, 1987 | Phil Niekro | P | 5x GG | 81%
|
| 99.3 | 1942 - 1964 | Warren Spahn | P | 1957 Cy Young | 81%
|
| 47.2 | 1976 - 1990 | Dale Murphy | CF | 5x GG, 4x SS, 1982 1983 MVP | 74%
|
| 33.3 | 1960 - 1968 | Joe Torre | C | GG | 45%
|
| 107.2 | 1890 - 1901 | Kid Nichols | P | 32%
| |
| 36.6 | 1930 - 1937 | Wally Berger | CF | 19%
| |
| 30.3 | 1912 - 1920, 1929 - 1935 | Rabbit Maranville | SS | 17%
| |
| 35.3 | 1890 - 1902 | Herman Long | SS | 13%
| |
| 35.9 | 1942 - 1952 | Tommy Holmes | RF | 13%
| |
| 42.1 | 1898 - 1905 | Vic Willis | P | 13%
| |
| 39.4 | 1894 - 1907, 1911 | Fred Tenney | 1B | 11%
| |
| 42.4 | 1888 - 1892 | John Clarkson | P | 11%
| |
| 40.1 | 1877 - 1881 | Tommy Bond | P | 6%
| |
| 28.7 | 1885 - 1895 | Billy Nash | 3B | 4%
| |
| 41.6 | 1881 - 1885 | Jim Whitney | P | 2%
|