| WAR | Years | Player | Pos. | Awards | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 52.5 | 2003 - 2016 | David Ortiz | DH | 7x SS | 98%
|
| 121.8 | 1939 - 1960 | Ted Williams | LF | 1946 1949 MVP | 98%
|
| 53.5 | 1998 - 2004 | Pedro Martínez | P | 1999 2000 Cy Young | 96%
|
| 80.8 | 1984 - 1996 | Roger Clemens | P | 1986 1987 1991 Cy Young, 1986 MVP | 92%
|
| 96.5 | 1961 - 1983 | Carl Yastrzemski | LF | 7x GG, 1967 MVP | 91%
|
| 41.3 | 1996 - 2004 | Nomar Garciaparra | SS | SS, 1997 ROY | 89%
|
| 51.9 | 2006 - 2019 | Dustin Pedroia | 2B | 4x GG, SS, 2007 ROY, 2008 MVP | 87%
|
| 42.5 | 2014 - 2019 | Mookie Betts | RF | 4x GG, 3x SS, 2018 MVP | 87%
|
| 66.7 | 1901 - 1908 | Cy Young | P | 81%
| |
| 71.9 | 1982 - 1992 | Wade Boggs | 3B | 6x SS | 81%
|
| 39.5 | 1969 - 1980 | Carlton Fisk | C | GG, 1972 ROY | 77%
|
| 47.7 | 1974 - 1989 | Jim Rice | LF | 2x SS, 1978 MVP | 68%
|
| 34.6 | 2013 - 2022 | Xander Bogaerts | SS | 5x SS | 66%
|
| 39.8 | 1914 - 1919 | Babe Ruth | P | 60%
| |
| 66.5 | 1972 - 1990 | Dwight Evans | RF | 8x GG, 2x SS | 55%
|
| 35.5 | 1971 - 1978 | Luis Tiant | P | 55%
| |
| 51.3 | 1937 - 1951 | Bobby Doerr | 2B | 40%
| |
| 55.7 | 1907 - 1915 | Tris Speaker | CF | 1912 MVP | 36%
|
| 34.2 | 1966 - 1973 | Reggie Smith | CF | GG | 34%
|
| 39.1 | 1963 - 1976 | Rico Petrocelli | SS | 28%
| |
| 41.9 | 1934 - 1941 | Lefty Grove | P | 25%
| |
| 33.6 | 1940 - 1953 | Dom DiMaggio | CF | 23%
| |
| 38.8 | 1909 - 1920 | Harry Hooper | RF | 11%
| |
| 33.9 | 1908 - 1915 | Smoky Joe Wood | RF | 8%
|