| WAR | Years | Player | Pos. | Awards | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 48.0 | 1991 - 2002, 2011 | Jim Thome | 1B | SS | 86%
|
| 57.6 | 2013 - Active | José Ramírez | 3B | 5x SS | 86%
|
| 63.4 | 1936 - 1956 | Bob Feller | P | 82%
| |
| 32.5 | 2011 - 2019 | Corey Kluber | P | 2014 2017 Cy Young | 73%
|
| 79.6 | 1902 - 1914 | Nap Lajoie | 2B | 68%
| |
| 48.6 | 1992 - 1996, 1998 - 2001, 2007 | Kenny Lofton | CF | 4x GG | 64%
|
| 74.9 | 1916 - 1926 | Tris Speaker | CF | 55%
| |
| 43.1 | 1947 - 1955, 1958 | Larry Doby | CF | 41%
| |
| 61.7 | 1938 - 1950 | Lou Boudreau | SS | 1948 MVP | 41%
|
| 48.2 | 1946 - 1958 | Bob Lemon | P | 36%
| |
| 51.2 | 1929 - 1939 | Earl Averill | CF | 27%
| |
| 35.0 | 1910 - 1915 | Joe Jackson | RF | 23%
| |
| 45.3 | 1902 - 1910 | Addie Joss | P | 18%
| |
| 39.7 | 1949 - 1957, 1963 | Early Wynn | P | 18%
| |
| 41.6 | 1961 - 1971 | Sam McDowell | P | 18%
| |
| 45.8 | 1920 - 1930 | Joe Sewell | SS | 14%
| |
| 33.1 | 1937 - 1949 | Ken Keltner | 3B | 9%
| |
| 44.3 | 1928 - 1947 | Mel Harder | P | 9%
| |
| 38.5 | 1904 - 1918 | Terry Turner | SS | 9%
| |
| 53.5 | 1916 - 1924 | Stan Coveleski | P | 5%
| |
| 35.8 | 1927 - 1933 | Wes Ferrell | P | 5%
| |
| 34.5 | 1901 - 1910 | Bill Bradley | 3B | 0%
| |
| 37.8 | 1919 - 1928, 1936 | George Uhle | P | 0%
| |
| 32.4 | 1926 - 1940 | Willis Hudlin | P | 0%
|