| WAR | Years | Player | Pos. | Awards | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 88.6 | 1973 - 1993 | George Brett | 3B | GG, 3x SS, 1980 MVP | 97%
|
| 21.7 | 2022 - Active | Bobby Witt Jr. | SS | 2x GG, SS | 87%
|
| 35.3 | 2011 - Active | Salvador Perez | C | 5x GG, 5x SS | 87%
|
| 40.7 | 1984 - 1991 | Bret Saberhagen | P | GG, 1985 1989 Cy Young | 84%
|
| 29.9 | 2004 - 2010, 2022 - 2023 | Zack Greinke | P | 2009 Cy Young | 77%
|
| 24.8 | 1998 - 2004 | Carlos Beltrán | CF | 1999 ROY | 52%
|
| 34.8 | 2007 - 2020 | Alex Gordon | LF | 8x GG | 48%
|
| 34.8 | 1973 - 1990 | Frank White | 2B | 8x GG, SS | 48%
|
| 44.8 | 1970- 1983 | Amos Otis | CF | 3x GG | 45%
|
| 42.4 | 1976 - 1989 | Willie Wilson | CF | GG, 2x SS | 45%
|
| 25.3 | 1979 - 1988 | Dan Quisenberry | P | 42%
| |
| 47.0 | 1989 - 1999, 2003 - 2004 | Kevin Appier | P | 42%
| |
| 24.6 | 2011 - 2017 | Lorenzo Cain | CF | 42%
| |
| 38.0 | 1984 - 1996 | Mark Gubicza | P | 32%
| |
| 27.6 | 1973 - 1987 | Hal McRae | DH | SS | 29%
|
| 21.4 | 1972 - 1977 | John Mayberry | 1B | 29%
| |
| 23.3 | 1995 - 2007 | Mike Sweeney | 1B | 29%
| |
| 23.0 | 1970 - 1984 | Paul Splittorff | P | 29%
| |
| 20.9 | 1988 - 1999 | Jeff Montgomery | P | 23%
| |
| 25.7 | 1974 - 1986 | Dennis Leonard | P | 19%
| |
| 20.5 | 1971 - 1979 | Freddie Patek | SS | 16%
| |
| 18.8 | 1976 - 1985 | Larry Gura | P | 16%
| |
| 20.2 | 2011 - 2021 | Danny Duffy | P | 13%
| |
| 22.9 | 1984 - 1989 | Charlie Leibrandt | P | 6%
|