| # | Team | Player | Years | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4 | LAD | Clayton Kershaw | 2011, 2013, 2014, 2014 | 100%
|
| 4 | ATL | Greg Maddux | 1992, 1993, 1994, 1995 | 100%
|
| 2 | NYY | Aaron Judge | 2022, 2024 | 96%
|
| 3 | STL | Albert Pujols | 2005, 2008, 2009 | 96%
|
| 7 | SFG | Barry Bonds | 1990, 1992, 1993, 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004 | 96%
|
| 2 | PHI | Bryce Harper | 2015, 2021 | 96%
|
| 3 | BOS | Pedro Martinez | 1997, 1999, 2000 | 96%
|
| 8 | BOS | Roger Clemens | 1986, 1986, 1987, 1991, 1997, 1998, 2001, 2004 | 96%
|
| 2 | NYY | Lou Gehrig | 1927, 1936 | 93%
|
| 3 | NYY | Mickey Mantle | 1956, 1957, 1962 | 93%
|
| 2 | DET | Miguel Cabrera | 2012, 2013 | 93%
|
| 3 | LAA | Mike Trout | 2014, 2016, 2019 | 93%
|
| 5 | SEA | Randy Johnson | 1995, 1999, 2000, 2001, 2002 | 93%
|
| 4 | LAD | Sandy Koufax | 1963, 1963, 1965, 1966 | 93%
|
| 3 | LAD | Shohei Ohtani | 2021, 2023, 2024 | 93%
|
| 2 | WSH | Walter Johnson | 1913, 1924 | 93%
|
| 3 | NYY | Yogi Berra | 1951, 1954, 1955 | 93%
|
| 3 | NYY | Alex Rodriguez | 2003, 2005, 2007 | 89%
|
| 2 | BAL | Cal Ripken Jr. | 1983, 1991 | 89%
|
| 2 | CHC | Ernie Banks | 1958, 1959 | 89%
|
| 3 | PHI | Mike Schmidt | 1980, 1981, 1986 | 89%
|
| 2 | NYY | Roger Maris | 1960, 1961 | 89%
|
| 4 | PHI | Steve Carlton | 1972, 1977,1980, 1982 | 89%
|
| 2 | ATL | Tom Glavine | 1991, 1998 | 89%
|
| 3 | NYM | Tom Seaver | 1969, 1973, 1975 | 89%
|
| 3 | STL | Bob Gibson | 1968, 1968, 1970 | 85%
|
| 2 | OAK | Dennis Eckersley | 1992, 1992 | 85%
|
| 3 | NYY | Joe DiMaggio | 1939, 1941, 1947 | 85%
|
| 4 | SFG | Justin Verlander | 2011, 2011, 2019, 2022 | 85%
|
| 2 | OAK | Rollie Fingers | 1981, 1981 | 85%
|
| 3 | STL | Stan Musial | 1943, 1946, 1948 | 85%
|
| 2 | BOS | Ted Williams | 1946, 1949 | 85%
|
| 2 | SFG | Willie Mays | 1954, 1965 | 85%
|
| 2 | CIN | Frank Robinson | 1961, 1966 | 81%
|
| 3 | PHA | Jimmie Foxx | 1932, 1933, 1938 | 81%
|
| 2 | CIN | Johnny Bench | 1970, 1972 | 81%
|
| 2 | DET | Hank Greenberg | 1935, 1940 | 78%
|
| 3 | BAL | Jim Palmer | 1973, 1975, 1976 | 78%
|
| 2 | TEX | Juan González | 1996, 1998 | 78%
|
| 3 | BRO | Roy Campanella | 1951, 1953, 1955 | 78%
|
| 2 | SFG | Tim Lincecum | 2008, 2009 | 78%
|
| 2 | OAK | Vida Blue | 1971, 1971 | 78%
|
| 2 | ATL | Dale Murphy | 1982, 1983 | 74%
|
| 2 | CHW | Frank Thomas | 1993, 1994 | 74%
|
| 2 | MIL | Robin Yount | 1982, 1989 | 74%
|
| 2 | BRO | Don Newcombe | 1956, 1956 | 70%
|
| 2 | TOR | Roy Halladay | 2003, 2010 | 70%
|
| 3 | DET | Denny McLain | 1968, 1968, 1969 | 67%
|
| 2 | DET | Hal Newhouser | 1944, 1945 | 67%
|
| 2 | HOU | Joe Morgan | 1975, 1976 | 63%
|
| 2 | CLE | Corey Kluber | 2014, 2017 | 59%
|
| 2 | SFG | Gaylord Perry | 1972, 1978 | 59%
|
| 3 | TOR | Max Scherzer | 2013, 2016, 2017 | 59%
|
| 2 | STL | Rogers Hornsby | 1925, 1929 | 59%
|
| 2 | KCR | Bret Saberhagen | 1985, 1989 | 56%
|
| 2 | MIN | Johan Santana | 2004, 2006 | 56%
|
| 2 | TEX | Jacob deGrom | 2018, 2019 | 52%
|
| 2 | PHA | Mickey Cochrane | 1928, 1934 | 48%
|
| 2 | NYG | Carl Hubbell | 1933, 1936 | 44%
|
| 2 | CHC | Willie Hernández | 1984, 1984 | 41%
|
| 2 | LAD | Blake Snell | 2018, 2023 | 33%
|