| WAR | Years | Player | Pos. | Awards | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 78.8 | 1967 - 1977, 1983 | Tom Seaver | P | 1967 ROY, 1969 1973 1975 Cy Young | 93%
|
| 23.3 | 2019 - Active | Pete Alonso | 1B | 2019 ROY | 91%
|
| 36.6 | 1983 - 1990 | Darryl Strawberry | RF | 2x SS, 1983 ROY | 89%
|
| 43.9 | 2014 - 2022 | Jacob deGrom | P | 2014 ROY, 2018 2019 Cy Young | 88%
|
| 49.1 | 2004 - 2018 | David Wright | 3B | 2x GG, 2x SS | 86%
|
| 46.4 | 1984 - 1994 | Dwight Gooden | P | SS, 1984 ROY, 1985 Cy Young | 86%
|
| 27.3 | 2021 - Active | Francisco Lindor | SS | 2x SS | 82%
|
| 24.6 | 1998 - 2005 | Mike Piazza | C | 5x SS | 82%
|
| 26.6 | 1983 - 1989 | Keith Hernandez | 1B | 5x GG, SS | 74%
|
| 27.7 | 2003 - 2011, 2016 - 2018 | José Reyes | SS | SS | 70%
|
| 26.1 | 2016 - Active | Brandon Nimmo | CF | 68%
| |
| 23.0 | 2018 - Active | Jeff McNeil | 2B | SS | 61%
|
| 31.1 | 2005 - 2011 | Carlos Beltrán | CF | 3x GG, 2x SS | 60%
|
| 36.9 | 1967 - 1978 | Jerry Koosman | P | 54%
| |
| 22.0 | 1985 - 1993 | Howard Johnson | 3B | 2x SS | 47%
|
| 18.1 | 1963 - 1975 | Cleon Jones | LF | 46%
| |
| 20.8 | 1980 - 1989 | Mookie Wilson | CF | 46%
| |
| 20.2 | 1987 - 1992, 2003 | David Cone | P | 39%
| |
| 29.2 | 1984 - 1993 | Sid Fernandez | P | 37%
| |
| 18.6 | 1965 - 1977 | Bud Harrelson | SS | GG | 30%
|
| 29.6 | 1995 - 2002 | Edgardo Alfonzo | 2B | SS | 30%
|
| 26.4 | 1998 - 2004 | Al Leiter | P | 26%
| |
| 27.0 | 1971 - 1977 | Jon Matlack | P | 1972 ROY | 26%
|
| 19.6 | 1975 - 1984 | John Stearns | C | 21%
|