| WAR | Years | Player | Pos. | Awards | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 120.3 | 1900 - 1917 | Honus Wagner | SS | 96%
| |
| 94.9 | 1955 - 1972 | Roberto Clemente | RF | 12x GG, 1966 MVP | 96%
|
| 57.6 | 1962 - 1982 | Willie Stargell | LF | 1979 MVP | 96%
|
| 42.6 | 2009 - 2017, 2023 - Active | Andrew McCutchen | CF | GG, 4x SS, 2013 MVP | 92%
|
| 50.3 | 1986 - 1992 | Barry Bonds | LF | 3x GG, 3x SS, 1990 1992 MVP | 88%
|
| 34.8 | 1973 - 1983 | Dave Parker | RF | 3x GG, 1978 MVP | 73%
|
| 31.0 | 1987 - 1994 | Andy Van Slyke | CF | 5x GG, 2x SS | 62%
|
| 36.4 | 1956 - 1972 | Bill Mazeroski | 2B | 8x GG | 62%
|
| 70.2 | 1926 - 1940 | Paul Waner | RF | 1927 MVP | 62%
|
| 30.7 | 1996 - 2004 | Jason Kendall | C | 58%
| |
| 43.3 | 1946 - 1953 | Ralph Kiner | LF | 58%
| |
| 42.3 | 1951 - 1965 | Bob Friend | P | 38%
| |
| 32.4 | 1950 - 1967 | Vern Law | P | 1960 Cy Young | 38%
|
| 38.8 | 1920 - 1937 | Pie Traynor | 3B | 35%
| |
| 67.5 | 1932 - 1941 | Arky Vaughan | SS | 31%
| |
| 46.9 | 1900 - 1915 | Fred Clarke | LF | 27%
| |
| 53.5 | 1910 - 1926 | Max Carey | CF | 27%
| |
| 34.0 | 1975 - 1985, 1993 | John Candelaria | P | 19%
| |
| 53.0 | 1907 - 1926 | Babe Adams | P | 12%
| |
| 36.5 | 1900 - 1912, 1918 | Tommy Leach | 3B | 8%
| |
| 52.3 | 1912 - 1924 | Wilbur Cooper | P | 8%
| |
| 31.5 | 1900 - 1911 | Deacon Phillippe | P | 4%
| |
| 30.8 | 1897- 1902 | Jesse Tannehill | P | 0%
| |
| 40.5 | 1898 - 1910 | Sam Leever | P | 0%
|