| Hint | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Have a 50/50 season | Shohei Ohtani | 100%
|
| Pitch a perfect game in a World Series | Don Larsen | 75%
|
| Has number retired by all MLB teams | Jackie Robinson | 75%
|
| With 200 wins and 100 saves | John Smoltz | 75%
|
| Hit 2 Gand Slams in the same inning. | Fernando Tatis | 50%
|
| Get 10 straight 200 hit seasons | Ichiro Suzuki | 50%
|
| Knuckleballer to win Cy Young | R.A. Dickey | 50%
|
| Steal home over 50 times in a career | Ty Cobb | 50%
|
| Have 300 steals, 300 Home Runs, and 3,000 hits. | Willie Mays | 50%
|
| Win 3 consecutive World Series with 3 different teams | Will Smith | 50%
|
| Win Rookie of the Year and Cy Young in the same year | Fernando Valenzuela | 25%
|
| Record over 60 saves in a single season | Francisco Rodriguez | 25%
|
| Throw back to back no hitters | Johnny Vander Meer | 25%
|
| Besides above answer to have number retired by more than 2 teams | Nolan Ryan | 25%
|
| Hit a Home Run without being credited with scoring a run | Bengie Molina | 0%
|
| Play in College World Series and World Series in the same year | Brandon Finnegan | 0%
|
| Win the Cy Young with a losing record | Eric Gagne | 0%
|
| Win MVP in the only year they received MVP votes | Ken Caminiti | 0%
|
| Hit 10 Home Runs in a single postseason | Randy Arozarena | 0%
|
| Was the starting pitcher in 3 straight games in the modern era | Zack Greinke | 0%
|