| Category | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| NLCS Loser | Houston Astros | 100%
|
| ALCS Loser | New York Yankees | 100%
|
| NL MVP (STL) | Albert Pujols | 83%
|
| Wins Leader (21 BOS) | Curt Schilling | 83%
|
| Saves Leader (53 NYY) | Mariano Rivera | 83%
|
| World Series Loser | St. Louis Cardinals | 83%
|
| Best Record (105-57) | St. Louis Cardinals | 83%
|
| WAR Leader (10.6 SFG) | Barry Bonds | 67%
|
| World Series Winner | Boston Red Sox | 67%
|
| Hits Leader (262 SEA) | Ichiro Suzuki | 67%
|
| Batting Champion (.372 SEA) | Ichiro Suzuki | 67%
|
| AL Cy Young (MIN) | Johan Santana | 67%
|
| Strike Outs Leader (290 ARI) | Randy Johnson | 67%
|
| AL MVP (ANA) | Vladimir Guerrero | 67%
|
| Worst Record (51-111) | Arizona Diamondbacks | 50%
|
| ERA Leader (2.27 SDP) | Jake Peavy | 50%
|
| NL Cy Young (HOU) | Rodger Clemens | 50%
|
| Home Run Leader (48 LAD) | Adrian Beltre | 33%
|
| RBI Leader (150 BAL) | Miguel Tejada | 33%
|
| Triples Leader (19 TBD) | Carl Crawford | 17%
|
| Name 1 HOF Inductee (DE, PM) | Dennis Eckersley | Paul Molitor | 17%
|
| NL Rookie of the Year (PIT) | Jason Bay | 17%
|
| Stolen Base Leader (70 MIL) | Scott Podsednik | 17%
|
| AL Rookie of the Year (OAK) | Bobby Crosby | 0%
|
| Doubles Leader (53 MIL) | Lyle Overbay | 0%
|