| Category | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| WAR Leader (8.5 STL) | Albert Pujols | 100%
|
| ALCS Loser | Oakland Athletics | 100%
|
| World Series Winner | St. Louis Cardinals | 100%
|
| World Series Loser | Detroit Tigers | 67%
|
| Saves Leader (47 LAA) | Francisco Rodriguez | 67%
|
| Batting Champion (.347 MIN) | Joe Mauer | 67%
|
| NLCS Loser | New York Mets | 67%
|
| Best Record (97 - 65) | New York Mets | New York Yankees | 67%
|
| Name 1 HOF Inductee (RB, WB, AC, PH, BM, JM, LS, BS, MS, BT, CT, JW) | Ray Brown | Willard Brown | Andy Cooper | Pete Hill | Biz Mackey | José Méndez | Louis Santop | Bruce Sutter | Mule Suttles | Ben Taylor | Cristóbal Torriente | Jud Wilson | 67%
|
| NL MVP (PHI) | Ryan Howard | 67%
|
| Home Run Leader (58 PHI) | Ryan Howard | 67%
|
| RBI Leader (149 RBI) | Ryan Howard | 67%
|
| NL Cy Young (ARI) | Brandon Webb | 33%
|
| NL Rookie of the Year (FLA) | Hanley Ramirez | 33%
|
| Hits Leader (224 SEA) | Ichiro Suzuki | 33%
|
| AL Cy Young (MIN) | Johan Santana | 33%
|
| ERA Leader (2.77 MIN) | Johan Santana | 33%
|
| Strike Outs Leader (245 MIN) | Johan Santana | 33%
|
| Wins Leader (19 MIN, NYY) | Johan Santana | Chien-Ming Wang | 33%
|
| Triples Leader (17 NYM) | Jose Reyes | 33%
|
| Stolen Base Leader (64 NYM) | Jose Reyes | 33%
|
| AL MVP (MIN) | Justin Morneau | 33%
|
| Worst Record (61 - 101) | Tampa Bay Devil Rays | 33%
|
| Doubles Leader (53 PIT, CLE) | Freddy Sanchez | Grady Sizemore | 0%
|
| AL Rookie of the Year (DET) | Justin Verlander | 0%
|