| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Kevin McCallister / Harry Lyme / Marv Murchins / Peter McCallister / Marley | Home Alone | 96%
|
| Cindy Lou Who / Donna Who / Bricklebaum / Mayor McGerkle / Groopert | The Grinch | 83%
|
| John McClane / Hans Gruber / Karl / Holly Gennaro-McClane / Al Powell | Die Hard | 80%
|
| Oswald Cobblepot (Penguin) / Selina Kyle (Catwoman) / Max Shreck / Alfred Pennyworth | Batman Returns | 71%
|
| George Bailey / Mary Hatch / Mr. Potter / Uncle Billy / Clarence | It's a Wonderful Life | 66%
|
| Linus van Pelt / Lucille "Lucy" van Pelt / Sally Brown / Pig-Pen / Snoopy | A Charlie Brown Christmas | 61%
|
| Clark W. "Sparky" Griswold Jr. / Ellen Griswold / Audrey Griswold / Russell "Rusty" Griswold | National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation | 59%
|
| Scott Calvin (Santa Claus) / Charlie Calvin / Laura Miller / Dr. Neil Miller / Bernard The Head Elf | The Santa Clause | 59%
|
| Ebenezer Scrooge / The Great Gonzo / Kermit the Frog / Miss Piggy / Fozzie Bear | The Muppet Christmas Carol | 57%
|
| Buddy Hobbs / Walter Hobbs / Jovie / Emily Hobbs / Santa Claus | Elf | 56%
|
| Josephine "Jo" March / Margaret "Meg" March / Amy March / Elizabeth "Beth" March / Marmee March | Little Women | 44%
|
| Harry / Karen / David, the Prime Minister / Juliet / Jamie | Love Actually | 40%
|
| Kris Kringle / Dorey Walker / Bryan Bedford / Ed Collins / Jack Duff | Miracle on 34th Street | 36%
|
| Louis Winthorpe III / Billy Ray Valentine / Randolph Duke / Mortimer Duke / Coleman | Trading Places | 27%
|
| Bob Wallace / Phil Davis / Betty Haynes / Judy Haynes / Major General Tom Waverly | White Christmas | 23%
|
| Billy Peltzer / Kate Beringer / Randall "Rand" Peltzer / Ruby Deagle / Lynn Peltzer | Gremlins | 20%
|
| Hero Boy / Hero Girl / Know-it-all / Billy the Lonely Boy / Sister Sarah | The Polar Express | 17%
|
| Willie T. Stokes / Marcus Skidmore / Thurman Merman / Gin Slagel / Bob Chipeska | Bad Santa | 14%
|
| Frank Cross / Claire Phillips / Lew Hayward / Brice Cummings / Eliot Loudermilk | Scrooged | 14%
|
| Iris Simpkins / Amanda Woods / Graham Simpkins / Miles Dumont | The Holiday | 13%
|
| Kim Boggs / Peg Boggs / Joyce Monroe / The Inventor / Helen | Edward Scissorhands | 11%
|
| Howard Langston / Myron Larabee / Ted Maltin / Liz Langston / Jamie Langston | Jingle All the Way | 11%
|
| Buddy Hall / Dr. Steve Finch / Kelly Finch / Tia Hall / Madison Finch | Deck the Halls | 7%
|
| Ray / Ken Daley / Harry Waters / Chloë Villette / Jimmy | In Bruges | 7%
|
| Calvin Clifford (C.C.) "Bud" Baxter / Fran Kubelik / Jeff D. Sheldrake / Joe Dobisch / Dr. David Dreyfuss | The Apartment | 6%
|