| Catchphrase/description | Creepypasta | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Go to SLEEP | Jeff the Killer | 94%
|
| You can't spell slaughter without laughter! | Laughing Jack | 86%
|
| Just empty, black sockets | Eyeless Jack | 81%
|
| Hooded killer | Hoodie | 78%
|
| Masked killer | Masky | 78%
|
| Do you like nature, Child? | Slenderman | 77%
|
| Don't go to sleep, you won't wake up | Jane the killer | 75%
|
| You shouldn't have done that | BEN drowned | 70%
|
| Spead the word | Smile Dog | 67%
|
| Who needs a social life when you have the voices in your head to keep you company? | Ticci Toby | 66%
|
| Your time is up | Clockwork | 62%
|
| HE COMES | Zalgo | 57%
|
| I AM GOD | Sonic.exe | 53%
|
| Don't be excited about tomorrow, because there will be no tomorrow | Bloody Painter | 52%
|
| Daughter of Zalgo | Lazari | 51%
|
| Give me your eyes | Lulu | 50%
|
| Play with me | Sally Williams | 48%
|
| Makes stuffed animals, dolls, wax figures... | Jason the toymaker | 47%
|
| Go to sleep my Prince | Nina the killer | 47%
|
| He is ___ ____ | The Rake | 47%
|
| He died... | Lost silver | 41%
|
| Pop goes the weasel! | Laughing Jill | 40%
|
| I shall sentence you... | Judge Angels | 27%
|
| It's a wonderful day to kill! | Homicidal Liu | 26%
|
| 遊びたいか, おまえ?(Do you want to play?) | Kagekao | 25%
|
| Skeleton Marionette | Skin Taker | 25%
|
| Real suffering is not known | Suicide mouse | 24%
|
| Dream while you're wide awake | Candy Pop | 23%
|
| Joyful fruit | Happy Appy | 23%
|
| Human but not quite... | BOB | 20%
|
| I'm your only friend... | Puppeteer | 18%
|
| I have a new game we can play! | Mr. Widemouth | 16%
|
| You are coming with me… forever | Tails doll | 15%
|
| First Creepypasta | Ted the Caver | 13%
|
| Let's get you fixed up! | Nurse Ann | 9%
|
| Nobody saw it coming | Nathan the nobody | 6%
|