| Quote | Contestant | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| "Hi Pencil, aren't you glad I didn't vomit on you!" | Rocky | 91%
|
| "..." | Teardrop | 87%
|
| "It tried to eat me, but it missed me by a bit!" | Blocky | 77%
|
| “If we could walk in synchrony, it would be even better!” | Tennis Ball | 77%
|
| "Oh no, look at the next one!" | Bubble | 74%
|
| "Unless it is Dream Island I don't want to hear it!" | Flower | 74%
|
| "Liar, liar pants ablaze!" | Pencil | 74%
|
| "But don't you know how much energy that wastes?" | Leafy | 71%
|
| “You know, all crispy and everything!" | Firey | 70%
|
| "Ah, it's great to be alive!" | Ice Cube | 70%
|
| "This is red, I know it!" | Eraser | 68%
|
| "Yeah I love magic tricks, do it!" | Pen | 66%
|
| "Look, I'm sorry. Is really that big of a deal?" | Needle | 65%
|
| "I just knew you were gonna say that, cause I'm just so smart." | Pin | 65%
|
| "Blocky, this is all your fault!" | Golf Ball | 63%
|
| "It's OK, you just bake at a sub-dirt level." | Match | 63%
|
| "Hold on Coiny, I've got some business to take care of!" | Snowball | 62%
|
| "Leaveh." | Woody | 62%
|
| "We won, that's a relief." | Coiny | 57%
|
| "Yay, we finished." | Spongy | 57%
|