| Method of death | Character | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Succumbed to his tuberculosis or killed by Micah | Arthur Morgan | 89%
|
| Shot by John and Dutch on Mount Hagen as revenge | Micah Bell | 79%
|
| Shot in the chest by Susan | Molly O'Shea | 75%
|
| Shot in the chest by Andrew Milton | Hosea Matthews | 73%
|
| Hanged in Saint Denis | Colm O'Driscoll | 69%
|
| Decapitated by O'Driscoll Boys | Kieran Duffy | 65%
|
| Shot by two unnamed Pinkertons | Lenny Summers | 65%
|
| Shot in the chest by Dutch in Annesburg | Leviticus Cornwall | 65%
|
| Shot in the head by a Gray sniper | Sean MacGuire | 65%
|
| Shot in the chest by Micah and succumbed to her wounds | Susan Grimshaw | 64%
|
| Shot in the head by Abigail | Andrew Milton | 61%
|
| Drowned and fed to an alligator | Angelo Bronte | 60%
|
| Succumbed to a gunshot wound in front of his father | Eagle Flies | 54%
|
| Hanged by John or shot by Sadie | Cleet | 53%
|
| Succumbed to his tuberculosis | Thomas Downes | 51%
|
| Shot by John on Mount Hagen | Joe | 50%
|
| Tortured to death by Pinkerton offscreen | Leopold Strauss | 48%
|
| Suicide by burning alive | Catherine Braithwaite | 39%
|
| Shot by Andrew Milton and left to bleed out | Mac Callander | 38%
|
| Blown up with a cannon fired by Arthur | Alberto Fussar | 37%
|
| Shot in the gut and succumbed to wounds | Davey Callander | 37%
|
| Shot by either Arthur or Micah | Leigh Gray | 29%
|
| Shot and succumbed to wounds | Jenny Kirk | 28%
|
| Shot by Arthur at the Cornwall oil refinery | Henry Favours | 18%
|
| Shot in the chest by unnamed ship captain on Guarma | Levi Simon | 15%
|
| Shot by either Arthur or Micah | Archibald MacGregor | 14%
|