| Game | Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| RDR2 | Protagonist, RDR2 | Arthur Morgan | 98%
|
| RDR/RDR2 | Protagonist, RDR | John Marston | 95%
|
| RDR/RDR2 | Charismatic gang leader | Dutch van der Linde | 87%
|
| RDR/RDR2 | Son of RDR protagonist | Jack Marston | 85%
|
| RDR/RDR2 | Wife of RDR protagonist | Abigail Marston | 82%
|
| RDR/RDR2 | Elderly gang member; lumbago | Uncle | 82%
|
| RDR2 | Traitorous gang member | Micah Bell | 81%
|
| RDR2 | Native American gang member | Charles Smith | 79%
|
| RDR2 | Widowed gang member | Sadie Adler | 77%
|
| RDR/RDR2 | Army veteran gang member | Bill Williamson | 74%
|
| RDR/RDR2 | Mexican gang member; outlaw | Javier Escuella | 73%
|
| RDR2 | Pinkerton agent | Andrew Milton | 71%
|
| RDR2 | Rival gang leader | Colm O’Driscoll | 71%
|
| RDR2 | Gang member; cook | Simon Pearson | 69%
|
| RDR/RDR2 | Pinkerton agent | Edgar Ross | 68%
|
| RDR2 | Gang second-in-command; conman | Hosea Matthews | 68%
|
| RDR2 | Oil magnet; major antagonist | Leviticus Cornwall | 66%
|
| RDR2 | Gang member; former O’Driscoll | Kieran Duffy | 65%
|
| RDR2 | Gang member; camp boss | Susan Grimshaw | 65%
|
| RDR2 | Disappearing gang member | Josiah Trelawny | 63%
|
| RDR2 | Gang member; reverend | Orville Swanson | 63%
|
| RDR2 | Son of Native American chief | Eagle Flies | 61%
|
| RDR2 | Sheriff of Rhodes | Leigh Gray | 61%
|
| RDR2 | Scarlett Meadows matriarch | Catherine Braithwaite | 60%
|
| RDR2 | Irish gang member | Molly O’Shea | 60%
|
| RDR2 | Wapiti Native American chief | Rains Fall | 60%
|
| RDR2 | Italian mob leader in Saint Denis | Angelo Bronte | 58%
|
| RDR2 | Gang gunman | Lenny Summers | 58%
|
| RDR2 | Irish gang member; gunman | Sean MacGuire | 56%
|
| RDR2 | Gang member; thief | Tilly Jackson | 56%
|
| RDR2 | Lover of RDR2 protagonist | Mary Linton | 50%
|
| RDR2 | Gang member; thief and writer | Mary-Beth Gaskill | 48%
|
| RDR2 | Cuban ruler of Guarma | Alberto Fussar | 47%
|
| RDR2 | Gang member; conwoman | Karen Jones | 45%
|
| RDR | Famous gunslinger | Landon Ricketts | 42%
|
| RDR | New Austin rancher | Bonnie MacFarlane | 40%
|
| RDR | Arms dealer and drunk | Irish | 35%
|
| RDR2 | US Army colonel | Henry Favours | 32%
|
| RDR | Mexican Army captain | Vincente de Santa | 32%
|
| RDR2 | Guarma revolutionary | Hercule Fontaine | 31%
|
| RDR | Mexican rebel leader | Abraham Reyes | 27%
|
| RDR | Elderly conman | Nigel West Dickens | 24%
|
| RDR | Mexican Army colonel | Agustin Allende | 21%
|
| RDR | Pinkerton agent | Archer Fordham | 18%
|
| RDR | Armadillo sheriff | Leigh Johnson | 18%
|
| RDR | Mexican rebel | Luisa Fortuna | 16%
|
| RDR | Professor from Yale | Harold MacDougal | 15%
|
| RDR | Crazy treasure hunter | Seth Briars | 15%
|