| Clue | Alter-Ego | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| Caped Crusader | Bruce Wayne | Batman | 100%
|
| Boy in tights | Tim Drake | Robin | 100%
|
| Kryptonian | Clark Kent | Superman | 100%
|
| Man in tights | Dick Grayson | Nightwing | 96%
|
| Kryptonian's Cousin | Kara Danvers | Supergirl | 96%
|
| Fastest Man Alive | Barry Allen | The Flash | 96%
|
| Amazonian | Diana Prince | Wonder Woman | 96%
|
| Atlantian | Arthur Curry | Aquaman | 93%
|
| Paralyzed Genius | Barbara Gordon | Batgirl | 93%
|
| You'd love to be him | Billy Batson | SHAZAM | 89%
|
| Red-Haired Crusader | Kate Kane | Batwoman | 86%
|
| Fastest Boy Alive | Wally West | Kid Flash | 86%
|
| Can shrink and embiggen | Raymond Palmer | The Atom | 82%
|
| Bike Helmet Guy | Jason Todd | Red Hood | 79%
|
| Kryptonian's Clone | Jonathan Kent | Superboy | 79%
|
| Amazonian | Donna Troy | Wonder Girl | 75%
|
| Magic Woman | ??? | Zatanna | 61%
|
| Atlantian | Kaldur'ahm | Aqualad | 57%
|
| Wears the Kryptonian's Emblem | John Irons | Steel | 43%
|
| Older Magic Man | Kent Nelson | Doctor Fate | 39%
|
| Magic Man | ??? | John Constantine | 14%
|
| First Fastest Man Alive | Jay Garrick | The original Flash | 11%
|