| Player | College | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Tom Brady | Michigan | 92%
|
| Cam Newton | Auburn | 88%
|
| Peyton Manning | Tennessee | 86%
|
| Aaron Rodgers | Cal | 85%
|
| Eli Manning | Ole Miss | 84%
|
| Andrew Luck | Stanford | 84%
|
| Matthew Stafford | Georgia | 83%
|
| Russell Wilson | Wisconsin or NC State | 83%
|
| Matt Cassel | USC | 82%
|
| Mark Sanchez | USC | 82%
|
| Carson Palmer | USC | 82%
|
| Robert Griffin III | Baylor | 81%
|
| Sam Bradford | Oklahoma | 77%
|
| Matt Schaub | Virginia | 76%
|
| Drew Brees | Purdue | 74%
|
| Michael Vick | Virginia Tech | 74%
|
| Matt Ryan | Boston College | 68%
|
| Alex Smith | Utah | 67%
|
| Andy Dalton | TCU | 65%
|
| Ryan Tannehill | Texas A&M | 62%
|
| Ryan Fitzpatrick | Harvard | 61%
|
| Ben Roethlisberger | Miami (OH) | 61%
|
| Joe Flacco | Delaware | 58%
|
| Phillip Rivers | NC State | 55%
|
| Jake Locker | Washington | 53%
|
| Christian Ponder | Florida State | 52%
|
| Brandon Weeden | Oklahoma State | 49%
|
| Jay Cutler | Vanderbilt | 49%
|
| Tony Romo | Eastern Illinois | 48%
|
| Blaine Gabbert | Missouri | 44%
|
| Josh Freeman | Kansas State | 31%
|
| John Skelton | Fordham | 8%
|