| Rank | Team/s | Position | Year Played | Fun Fact | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | Red Sox, Yankees, Braves | RF/LHP | 1914-35 | 714 Homeruns | Babe Ruth | 100%
|
| #3 | Pirates, Giants | LF | 1986-2007 | Hit 73 Homeruns in a single season | Barry Bonds | 94%
|
| #5 | Braves, Brewers | RF | 1954-76 | Most Career RBI's (2,297) | Hank Aaron | 94%
|
| #4 | Red Sox | LF | 1939-60 | .344 Hitter but had no 200 hit seasons | Ted Williams | 94%
|
| #2 | Giants, Mets | CF | 1951-73 | Played in 24 All-Star Games | Willie Mays | 94%
|
| #7 | Red Sox, Blue Jays, Yankees, Astros | RHP | 1984-2007 | Won 7 Cy Young Awards | Roger Clemens | 86%
|
| #9 | Yankees | OF | 1951-68 | World Series Record 18 Homers | Mickey Mantle | 84%
|
| #6 | Tigers, Athletics | CF | 1905-28 | Highest Career Average | Ty Cobb | 84%
|
| #8 | Cardinals | 1B/OF | 1941-63 | 1,815 hits both home and road | Stan Musial | 80%
|
| #10 | Pirates | SS | 1897-1917 | 8 Time Batting Champion | Honus Wagner | 78%
|
| #11 | Yankees | 1B | 1923-39 | 23 Grand Slams | Lou Gehrig | 78%
|
| #14 | A's, Yankees, Blue Jays, Angels, Mets, Mariners, Padres, Red Sox, Dodgers | LF | 1979-2003 | All-time leader in runs, steals | Rickey Henderson | 76%
|
| #13 | Braves, Cubs, Padres, Dodgers | RHP | 1986-2008 | Won 4 consecutive Cy Young Awards | Greg Maddux | 75%
|
| #16 | Phillies | 3B | 1972-89 | Led NL in homers eight times | Mike Schmidt | 73%
|
| #12 | Senators | RHP | 1907-27 | 6 wins, 1.14 ERA in 1913 | Walter Johnson | 71%
|
| #19 | Yankees | CF | 1936-51 | 361 home runs, 369 strikeouts | Joe Dimaggio | 67%
|
| #23 | Mariners, Rangers, Yankees | 3B, SS | 1996-2016 | Only SS with a 50-homer season | Alex Rodriguez | 65%
|
| #17 | Spiders, Americans | RHP | 1890-1911 | 94 wins more than anyone else | Cy Young | 65%
|
| #18 | A's Phillies, Giants, Astros, Reds | 2B | 1963-84 | Led NL OBP four times | Joe Morgan | 65%
|
| #26 | Reds | C | 1967-83 | Only catcher to lead league in total bases | Johnny Bench | 63%
|
| #21 | Giants, Diamondbacks, Yankees, Mariners, Astros, Nationals | LHP | 1988-2009 | Averaged 354 K's 1999-2002 | Randy Johnson | 63%
|
| #29 | Cardinals, Angels | 1B | 2001-Present | He and Miguel Cabrera are only Hall of 100 members to debut this century | Albert Pujols | 61%
|
| #32 | Orioles | SS, 3B | 1981-2001 | Won '91 AL MVP with 95-loss team | Cal Ripken Jr. | 61%
|
| #31 | Yankees | SS | 1995-2014 | Yankees' all-time steals leader | Derek Jeter | 61%
|
| #30 | Royals | 3B | 1973-93 | Won a batting title in three decades | George Brett | 61%
|
| #34 | Pirates | RF | 1955-72 | First homer was inside-the-parker in his third game | Roberto Clemente | 61%
|
| #22 | Mets, Reds, White Sox, Red Sox | RHP | 1967-86 | 2.47 ERA over first 10 seasons | Tom Seaver | 61%
|
| #33 | Cardinals | RHP | 1959-75 | Played for the Harlem Globetrotters in 1957-58 | Bob Gibson | 59%
|
| #27 | A's, Red Sox, Phillies, Cubs | 1B | 1925-45 | At least 30 homers and 100 RBIs each season from 1929-40 | Jimmie Foxx | 59%
|
| #35 | Mariners, Reds, White Sox | CF | 1989-2010 | Sixth all time in homers and extra-base hits | Ken Griffey Jr. | 59%
|
| #20 | Reds, Orioles, Dodgers, Indians | OF | 1956-76 | Only player to win MVP in both leagues | Frank Robinson | 57%
|
| #47 | Marlins, Tigers | 1B, 3B | 2003-Present | One of five players to win three straight AL batting titles | Miguel Cabrera | 57%
|
| #36 | Mets, Angels, Astros, Rangers | RHP | 1966-93 | Led NL in ERA (2.76) with 8-16 record in 1987 | Nolan Ryan | 57%
|
| #38 | Reds, Phillies, Expos | OF, 1B | 1963-86 | The Hit King was hitless until his 12th official at-bat | Pete Rose | 57%
|
| #44 | Dodgers | LHP | 1955-66 | 382 strikeouts in 1965 is most ever by a lefty | Sandy Koufax | 57%
|
| #46 | Tigers | RF | 1953-74 | Hit .340 at age 20 to become youngest batting champ ever | Al Kaline | 55%
|
| #40 | Red Sox | LF | 1961-83 | Led the AL in outfield assists seven times | Carl Yastrzemski | 55%
|
| #50 | Braves | 3B, LF | 1993-2012 | Fun fact: Record-tying 14 extra-base hits in 14 straight games in 2006 | Chipper Jones | 55%
|
| #53 | Cubs | SS, 1B | 1953-71 | Fun fact: Four straight 40-HR years at SS | Ernie Banks | 55%
|
| #52 | Yankees | RHP | 1995-2013 | Fun fact: 0.70 ERA in 96 playoff games | Mariana Rivera | 55%
|
| #41 | Dodgers,Expos, Red Sox | RHP | 1992-2009 | Struck out 5 of 6 hitters he faced in '99 All-Star Game | Pedro Martinez | 55%
|
| #55 | Twins, Angels | 2B, 1B | 1967-85 | Fun fact: Led MLB in OBP in '70s (.408) | Rod Carew | 55%
|
| #15 | Orioles, Cardinals, Cubs, Braves, Giants | 2B | 1915-37 | Led NL in BA/OBP/SLG each year from 1920-25 | Rogers Hornsby | 55%
|
| #63 | Padres | OF | 1982-2001 | Fun fact: Eight-time NL batting champion | Tony Gwynn | 55%
|
| #58 | Yankees, Mets | C | 1946-65 | Fun fact: Was a 15-time All-Star | Yogi Berra | 55%
|
| #43 | Orioles | 3B | 1955-77 | Hit .303 in nine postseason series, including .429 in 1970 World Series | Brooks Robinson | 53%
|
| #67 | Orioles, Dodgers, Indians, Mets, Angels | 1B | 1977-97 | Fun fact: AL Rookie of the Year in 1977 | Eddie Murray | 53%
|
| #70 | White Sox, A's, Jays | 1B | 1990-2008 | Fun fact: Two-time American League MVP | Frank Thomas | 53%
|
| #54 | Dodgers | 2B | 1947-56 | Fun fact: Stole home 19 times | Jackie Robinson | 53%
|
| #60 | Brewers | SS, CF | 1974-93 | Began big league career at age 18 | Robin Yount | 53%
|
| #56 | Red Sox, Yankees, Rays | 3B | 1982-99 | Fun fact: Led AL in OBP five straight years | Wade Boggs | 53%
|
| #59 | Giants, Padres, A's | 1B | 1959-80 | Fun fact: 18th all time with 521 home runs | Willie McCovey | 53%
|
| #91 | Astros | C, 2B | 1988-2007 | Fun fact: Stole 50 bases in 1998 | Craig Biggio | 51%
|
| #72 | Rangers, Tigers, Nationals, Rangers, Yankees, Marlins | C | 1991-2011 | Fun fact: AL MVP in 1999 | Ivan Rodriguez | 51%
|
| #69 | Astros | 1B | 1991-2005 | Fun fact: Scored over 100 runs nine times | Jeff Bagwell | 51%
|
| #76 | Braves, Red Sox, Cardinals | RHP | 1988-2009 | Fun fact: NL Cy Young winner in 1996 | John Smoltz | 51%
|
| #79 | Dodgers, Mets, Marlins, Padres, A's | C | 1992-2007 | Fun fact: Six 30-HR/100-RBI seasons | Mike Piazza | 51%
|
| #62 | Padres, Cardinals | SS | 1978-96 | Fun fact: 13-time Gold Glove winner | Ozzie Smith | 51%
|
| #85 | Pirates | 1B | 1962-82, | Fun fact: Won 1979 NL MVP at age 39 | Willie Stargell | 51%
|
| #75 | Reds | SS | 1986-2004 | Fun fact: NL MVP in 1995 | Barry Larkin | 49%
|
| #77 | Red Sox, White Sox | C | 1969-93 | Fun fact: 1972 ROY, 11-time All-Star | Carlton Fisk | 49%
|
| #87 | Expos, Mets, Dodgers, Giants | C | 1974-92 | Fun fact: 11-time All-Star, three-time Gold Glove winner | Gary Carter | 49%
|
| #66 | Senators, Twins, Royals | 3B | 1954-75 | Fun fact: Led AL in home runs six times | Harmon Killebrew | 49%
|
| #86 | Indians, Red Sox, Dodgers, White Sox, Rays | LF | 1993-2011, | Fun fact: Had a career-best 165 RBIs in '99 | Manny Ramirez | 49%
|
| #84 | Athletics, Cardinals | 1B | 1986-2001, | Fun fact: Hit a 538-foot home run off Randy Johnson in 1997 | Mark McGwire | 49%
|
| #57 | A's, Yankees, Angels, Orioles | OF | 1967-87 | Fun fact: World Series MVP for two teams | Reggie Jackson | 49%
|
| #95 | Rangers, White Sox, Cubs, Orioles | RF | 1989-2007 | Fun fact: Only player in history with three 60-homer seasons | Sammy Sosa | 49%
|
| #93 | Braves, Mets | LHP | 1987-2008 | Fun fact: 14-16, 3.30 ERA in postseason | Tom Glavine | 49%
|
| #61 | Indians | RHP | 1936-56 | Fun fact: Pitched 279 complete games | Bob Feller | 47%
|
| #39 | Braves, Astros, Tigers | 3B | 1952-68 | Only Brave to play for club in Boston, Milwaukee and Atlanta | Eddie Mathews | 47%
|
| #78 | Brewers, Jays, Twins | INF, DH | 1978-98 | Fun fact: 1993 World Series MVP | Paul Molitor | 47%
|
| #25 | Twins, Indians, Giants, Phillies, White Sox, Cardinals | LHP | 1965-88 | Won 27 of Phillies' 59 games in '72 | Steve Carlton | 47%
|
| #28 | Giants, Reds | RHP | 1900-16 | 0.97 World Series ERA (11 starts) | Christy Mathewson | 45%
|
| #90 | Orioles | RHP | 1965-84 | Fun fact: Winningest AL pitcher in the 1970s | Jim Palmer | 45%
|
| #74 | White Sox, Indians, Mets, Padres, Blue Jays, Orioles, Diamondbacks | 2B | 1988-2004 | 10-time Gold Glove winner | Roberto Alomar | 45%
|
| #24 | Royals, Twins, Indians, Red Sox | CF | 1907-28 | Most doubles (792) in history | Tris Speaker | 45%
|
| #94 | Indians, Phillies, White Sox, Dodgers, Twins, Orioles | 1B | 1991-2007 | Fun fact: .402 career OBP | Jim Thome | 43%
|
| #37 | Giants | RF, 3B | 1926-47 | Retired 65 years ago, but still ranks 12th all time in RBIs | Mel Ott | 43%
|
| #45 | Braves, Mets, Giants | LHP | 1942-65, | Didn't get the first win until age 25 | Warren Spahn | 43%
|
| #48 | A's, Red Sox | LHP | 1925-41 | Fun fact: Faced Babe Ruth for 10 years, gave up only nine homers to him | Lefty Grove | 41%
|
| #82 | Dodgers, Mets, Giants | CF | 1947-64 | Fun fact: Five straight 40-homer seasons | Duke Snider | 39%
|
| #65 | Tigers, Pirates | 1B, OF | 1930-47 | Two-time AL MVP | Hank Greenberg | 39%
|
| #97 | Cubs, White Sox | 3B | 1960-74 | Fun fact: Only 3B with eight straight 90-RBI seasons | Ron Santo | 39%
|
| #71 | Giants, Red Sox, Dodgers | RHP | 1960-75 | Fun fact: Pitched 244 complete games | Juan Marichal | 37%
|
| #73 | Twins, Pirates, others | RHP | 1970-92 | Fun fact: Two-time World Series winner | Bert Blyleven | 33%
|
| #68 | Giants, Indians, Mariners, Braves, Yankees, Padres, Rangers, Royals | RHP | 1962-85 | Fun fact: Won a Cy Young in both leagues | Gaylord Perry | 33%
|
| #49 | Phillies, A's, Indians | 2B | 1896-1916 | Fun fact: Said to be first player walked intentionally with bases loaded (1901) | Nap Lajoie | 33%
|
| #51 | Phillies, Cubs, Cardinals | RHP | 1911-1930 | Fun fact: Issued no walks in his first 53 innings in 1923 | Pete Alexander | 33%
|
| #96 | Expos, Yankees, Marlins, Orioles, Athletics's, White Sox | LF | 1979-2002 | Fun fact: 84.7 SB% is highest ever (min. 500 attempts) | Tim Raines | 33%
|
| #42 | White Sox, A's | 2B | 1906-1930 | All-time leader in assists (7,630) by a second baseman | Eddie Collins | 31%
|
| #100 | Braves, Yankees, Blue Jays, Indians | RHP | 1964-87 | Fun fact: Ranks fourth all time in innings pitched | Phil Niekro | 31%
|
| #80 | Phillies, Orioles, Astros, Cubs | RHP | 1948-66 | Fun fact: Pitched 28 consecutive complete games | Robin Roberts | 31%
|
| #64 | Phillies, Cubs, Rangers, Red Sox | RHP | 1965-83 | Fun fact: NL Cy Young winner in 1971 | Ferguson Jenkins | 29%
|
| #81 | Tigers | 2B | 1924-42 | Fun fact: Led AL 2B in fielding five times | Charlie Gehringer | 27%
|
| #89 | Forest Citys, Athletics, White Stockings | 1B | 1871-97 | Fun fact: Starred in the Broadway play "A Runaway Colt" | Cap Anson | 20%
|
| #98 | Red Sox, Senators | SS | 1926-45 | Fun fact: Served as AL president for 24 years | Joe Cronin | 18%
|
| #83 | Beaneaters, Cardinals, Phillies | RHP | 1890-1906 | Fun fact: Compiled 361 wins over 15 seasons | Kid Nichols | 18%
|
| #92 | Pirates, Braves, Dodgers, Yankees | RF | 1926-45 | Fun fact: Extra-base hit in 14 straight games in 1927 | Paul Waner | 18%
|
| #88 | Giants, Cardinals | 2B | 1919-37 | Fun fact: Went directly from Fordham to the majors | Frankie Frisch | 16%
|
| #99 | A's, White Sox,Tigers, Senators, Braves, Reds, Red Sox | OF | 1922-44 | Fun fact: 11 straight years of .300/100 | Al Simmons | 14%
|