| College | Year | Position | MVP | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ole Miss | 2007/2011 | Quarterback | Eli Manning | 100%
|
| Tennessee | 2006 | Quarterback | Peyton Manning | 100%
|
| Michigan | 2001/2003/2014/2016/2020 | Quarterback | Tom Brady | 100%
|
| Purdue | 2009 | Quarterback | Drew Brees | 95%
|
| Texas Tech | 2019 | Quarterback | Patrick Mahomes | 95%
|
| Butte College/California | 2010 | Quarterback | Aaron Rodgers | 91%
|
| Alabama | 1966/1967 | Quarterback | Bart Starr | 86%
|
| Florida | 1993 | Running Back | Emmitt Smith | 86%
|
| Notre Dame | 1981/1984/1989 | Quarterback | Joe Montana | 86%
|
| USC | 2013 | Linebacker | Malcolm Smith | 86%
|
| Arizona | 2017 | Quarterback | Nick Foles | 86%
|
| Mississippi Valley State | 1988 | Wide Receiver | Jerry Rice | 82%
|
| Alabama | 1968 | Quarterback | Joe Namath | 82%
|
| Northern Iowa | 1999 | Quarterback | Kurt Warner | 82%
|
| BYU | 1994 | Quarterback | Steve Young | 82%
|
| Louisiana Tech | 1978/1979 | Quarterback | Terry Bradshaw | 82%
|
| Pittsburgh/Delaware | 2012 | Quarterback | Joe Flacco | 77%
|
| Stanford | 1998 | Quarterback | John Elway | 77%
|
| Kent State | 2018 | Wide Receiver | Julian Edelman | 77%
|
| Purdue | 1969 | Quarterback | Len Dawson | 77%
|
| Navy | 1971 | Quarterback | Roger Staubach | 77%
|
| Oklahoma/UCLA | 1992 | Quarterback | Troy Aikman | 77%
|
| Eastern Washington | 2021 | Wide Receiver | Cooper Kupp | 73%
|
| Miami (Florida) | 2000 | Linebacker | Ray Lewis | 73%
|
| Penn State | 1974 | Fullback | Franco Harris | 68%
|
| USC | 1983 | Running Back | Marcus Allen | 68%
|
| Maryland | 1977 | Defensive Tackle | Randy White | 68%
|
| Grambling State | 1987 | Quarterback | Doug Williams | 64%
|
| Syracuse | 1973 | Fullback | Larry Csonka | 64%
|
| USC | 1975 | Wide Receiver | Lynn Swann | 64%
|
| Morehead State | 1986 | Quarterback | Phil Simms | 64%
|
| Texas A&M | 2015 | Linebacker | Von Miller | 64%
|
| Stanford | 1980 | Quarterback | Jim Plunkett | 59%
|
| Washington State | 1991 | Quarterback | Mark Rypien | 59%
|
| Michigan | 1996 | Return Specialist | Desmond Howard | 55%
|
| Georgia | 2005 | Wide Receiver | Hines Ward | 55%
|
| Kansas | 1982 | Fullback | John Riggins | 50%
|
| TCU | 1995 | Cornerback | Larry Brown | 50%
|
| Georgia | 1997 | Running Back | Terrell Davis | 50%
|
| Tennessee State | 1985 | Defensive End | Richard Dent | 45%
|
| Ohio State | 2008 | Wide Receiver | Santonio Holmes | 45%
|
| Florida State | 2002 | Safety | Dexter Jackson | 41%
|
| Florida State | 1976 | Wide Receiver | Fred Biletnikoff | 41%
|
| Louisville | 2004 | Wide Receiver | Deion Branch | 36%
|
| Miami (Florida) | 1990 | Running Back | Ottis Anderson | 36%
|
| West Virginia | 1970 | Linebacker | Chuck Howley | 32%
|
| Georgia | 1972 | Safety | Jake Scott | 32%
|
| East Texas State | 1977 | Defensive End | Harvey Martin | 27%
|