| # | Year | Team(s) | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 226 | 2004-12 | Everton | Tim Cahill | 92%
|
| 514 | 1996-97, 1998-2015 | Middlesbrough, Fulham, Chelsea, Leicester City | Mark Schwarzer | 82%
|
| 274 | 1995-2008 | Leeds United, Liverpool | Harry Kewell | 78%
|
| 240 | 2000-09 | Leeds United, Middlesbrough, Newcastle United | Mark Viduka | 67%
|
| 96 | 2017-20 | Huddersfield Town, Brighton | Aaron Mooy | 63%
|
| 124 | 2017-21 | Brighton, Arsenal | Mathew Ryan | 63%
|
| 206 | 1992-2000, 2001-02 | Aston Villa, Manchester United, Chelsea | Mark Bosnich | 57%
|
| 90 | 2013-17 | Crystal Palace | Mile Jedinak | 57%
|
| 247 | 2003-12 | Blackburn Rovers | Brett Emerton | 47%
|
| 45 | 2003-09, 2011-13, 2014-15 | Middlesbrough, Liverpool | Bradley Jones | 43%
|
| 10 | 2013-14, 2015-17 | Liverpool, Bournemouth | Brad Smith | 43%
|
| 279 | 2001-10 | Blackburn Rovers, West Ham, Everton | Lucas Neill | 39%
|
| 12 | 2022-23 | Leicester City | Harry Souttar | 33%
|
| 11 | 2024-25 | Ipswich Town | Massimo Luongo | 29%
|
| 18 | 2024-25 | Ipswich Town | Cameron Burgess | 24%
|
| 23 | 1999-2000 | Watford | Richard Johnson | 24%
|
| 25 | 2005-07 | Newcastle United | Craig Moore | 20%
|
| 42 | 1998-2001 | Coventry City | John Aloisi | 20%
|
| 166 | 1995-99, 2002-06 | West Ham, Birmingham City | Stan Lazaridis | 20%
|
| 31 | 2006-07, 2012-13, 2015-17 | Reading, Bournemouth | Adam Federici | 18%
|
| 84 | 1994-98 | Blackburn Rovers, West Ham, Southampton | Robbie Slater | 18%
|
| 3 | 2020-21 | Southampton | Caleb Watts | 16%
|
| 2 | 2020-21, 2022-23 | Fulham | Tyrese Francois | 16%
|
| 1 | 2022-23 | Brighton | Cameron Peupion | 14%
|
| 36 | 2010-14 | Aston Villa | Chris Herd | 14%
|
| 23 | 2004-05 | Crystal Palace | Tony Popovic | 14%
|
| 27 | 2012-13 | Aston Villa | Brett Holman | 12%
|
| 51 | 2000-01, 2002-04 | Manchester City | Danny Tiatto | 12%
|
| 9 | 1997-98 | Crystal Palace | Kevin Muscat | 12%
|
| 21 | 2001-03 | Middlesbrough | Luke Wilkshire | 12%
|
| 3 | 2016-17 | Burnley | Aiden O'Neill | 10%
|
| 21 | 2000-02, 2003-04 | West Ham, Portsmouth | Hayden Foxe | 10%
|
| 4 | 1995-96 | QPR | Ned Zelic | 10%
|
| 12 | 2002-03 | Middlesbrough | Tony Vidmar | 10%
|
| 1 | 2000-01 | Manchester City | Daniel Allsopp | 8%
|
| 11 | 2010-11 | Blackpool | David Carney | 8%
|
| 6 | 2000-01, 2002-03 | Leeds United | Jacob Burns | 8%
|
| 4 | 2002–03 | Leeds United | Jamie McMaster | 8%
|
| 4 | 2015-16 | Aston Villa | Jordan Lyden | 8%
|
| 49 | 2001-02, 2008-10 | West Ham, Hull City | Richard García | 8%
|
| 38 | 2008-12 | Blackburn Rovers | Vince Grella | 8%
|
| 6 | 1992-93, 1994-95 | Everton | Jason Kearton | 6%
|
| 74 | 1994-99, 2005-07 | Coventry City, Blackburn Rovers, Wigan Athletic | John Filan | 6%
|
| 45 | 2005-08 | Wigan Athletic | Josip Skoko | 6%
|
| 12 | 2007-08 | Derby County | Mile Sterjovski | 6%
|
| 18 | 2005-06 | Birmingham City | Neil Kilkenny | 6%
|
| 43 | 2000-03 | Middlesbrough, Leeds United | Paul Okon | 6%
|
| 6 | 1997-98 | Crystal Palace | Carl Veart | 4%
|
| 1 | 1996-97 | West Ham | Steve Mautone | 4%
|
| 6 | 2005-06 | Fulham | Ahmad Elrich | 2%
|
| 11 | 1992-93, 1998-99 | Ipswich Town, Charlton Athletic | Andy Petterson | 2%
|
| 1 | 1998–99 | West Ham | Chris Coyne | 2%
|
| 2 | 2014-15 | West Bromwich Albion | Jason Davidson | 2%
|
| 2 | 2001-02 | Southampton | Scott McDonald | 2%
|