| Island | Country | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| North Island | New Zealand | 100%
|
| South Island | New Zealand | 100%
|
| Tasmania | Australia | 100%
|
| New Guinea | Indonesia, Papua New Guinea | 94%
|
| New Caledonia | France | 85%
|
| Bougainville Island | Papua New Guinea | 79%
|
| Hawai'i | United States | 76%
|
| New Britain | Papua New Guinea | 70%
|
| New Ireland | Papua New Guinea | 70%
|
| Viti Levu | Fiji | 67%
|
| Vanua Levu | Fiji | 61%
|
| Guadalcanal | Solomon Islands | 55%
|
| Espiritu Santo | Vanuatu | 36%
|
| Kangaroo Island | Australia | 33%
|
| Choiseul Island | Solomon Islands | 30%
|
| K'gari | Australia | 24%
|
| Malaita | Solomon Islands | 24%
|
| Savai'i | Samoa | 24%
|
| Stewart Island | Rakiura | New Zealand | 21%
|
| Malakula | Vanuatu | 18%
|
| Manus | Papua New Guinea | 18%
|
| Melville Island | Australia | 18%
|
| Groote Eylandte | Australia | 15%
|
| Makira | Solomon Islands | 15%
|
| New Georgia | Solomon Islands | 15%
|