| Rank | Province/Territory | Area (sqkm) | Island | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Newfoundland and Labrador | 108,860 | Newfoundland | 100%
|
| 3. | British Colombia | 31,285 | Vancouver Island | 90%
|
| 2. | Northwest Territories | 70,028 | Banks Island | 77%
|
| 8. | Prince Edward Island | 5,620 | Prince Edward Island | 77%
|
| 5. | Nova Scotia | 10,311 | Cape Breton Island | 60%
|
| 6. | Quebec | 7,941 | Anticosti Island | 57%
|
| 9. | Ontario | 2,766 | Manitoulin Island | 37%
|
| 7. | British Colombia | 6,361 | Graham Island | 33%
|
| 10. | British Colombia | 2,608 | Moresby Island | 27%
|
| 4. | Northwest Territories | 15,848 | Prince Patrick Island | 23%
|