| Hint | Character | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Love of #1's life | Daisy Buchanan | 99%
|
| The Book's Namesake | Jay Gatsby | 99%
|
| The Narrator | Nick Carroway | 98%
|
| Husband of the Above (#4) | Tom Buchanan | 95%
|
| Narrator's Girlfriend | Jordan Baker | 90%
|
| Husband of the Above (#6) | George Wilson | 83%
|
| Gangster, Associate of #1 | Meyer Wolfsheim | 63%
|
| Lover of the Above (#5) | Myrtle Wilson | 61%
|
| Strange Man who first appears in a library | Owl-Eyed Man | 51%
|
| Mentor of #1 | Dan Cody | 49%
|
| Sister of #5 | Catherine | 33%
|
| Daughter of #4 and #5 | Pammy Buchanon | 28%
|