| Letter | Song | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| P | Piano Man | Pressure | Prelude/Angry Young Man | 91%
|
| S | The Stranger | Scenes from an Italian Restaurant | + 10 | 78%
|
| W | We Didn't Start the Fire | Why Should I Worry? | + 5 | 76%
|
| U | Uptown Girl | Until the Night | 72%
|
| M | Movin' Out | My Life | + 5 | 71%
|
| V | Vienna | 70%
|
| A | All About Soul | All For Leyna | + 8 | 68%
|
| Z | Zanzibar | 58%
|
| L | Leave a Tender Moment Alone | The Longest Time | + 4 | 56%
|
| I | I Go To Extremes | An Innocent Man | + 5 | 55%
|
| N | New York State of Mind | No Man's Land | + 3 | 54%
|
| B | Baby Grand | Big Shot | + 4 | 53%
|
| R | River of Dreams | Root Beer Rag | + 3 | 49%
|
| Y | You May Be Right | You're My Home | + 4 | 49%
|
| O | Only The Good Die Young | 47%
|
| T | Tell Her About It | This is the Time | + 8 | 47%
|
| J | Just The Way You Are | James | 46%
|
| C | Captain Jack | C'Était Toi | + 5 | 45%
|
| E | The Entertainer | Easy Money | + 2 | 45%
|
| D | Don't Ask Me Why | The Downeaster Alexa | 44%
|
| G | Goodnight Saigon | Get It Right the First Time | + 2 | 43%
|
| H | Honesty | Half a Mile Away | 31%
|
| # | 52nd Street | 29%
|
| K | Keeping the Faith | 22%
|
| F | Famous Last Words | Falling of the Rain | 13%
|