| Clues | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Owner of the Hotel, Meryl Streep, Lily James | Donna Sheridan | 99%
|
| Daughter of Number 1, Sender of the letters, Amanda Seyfried | Sophie Sheridan | 96%
|
| Swedish sailor and travel writer, Possible father of Number 2, Stellan Skarsgård | Bill Anderson | 95%
|
| Irish-American Architect, Possible father of Number 2, Pierce Brosnan | Sam Carmichael | 94%
|
| British Banker, Possible father of Number 2, Colin Firth | Harry Bright | 93%
|
| Husband of Number 2, Father of Donny, Dominic Cooper | Sky Ramand | 85%
|
| Wealthy Friend of Number 1, Christina Baranski, Jessica Keenan Wynn | Tanya Chesham-Leigh | 85%
|
| Writer Friend of Number 1, Julie Walters, Alexa Davies | Rosie Mulligan | 82%
|
| Mexican manager of the hotel, Lover of Number 9, Andy Garcia | Señor Fernando Cienfuegos | 56%
|
| Famous Singer, Mother of Number 1, Cher | Rubie Sheridan | 12%
|