| Team | Years Active At Club | Top Appearance Holder | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| Manchester United | 1991-2014 | Ryan Giggs (963) | 100%
|
| Arsenal | 1975-1993 | David O'Leary (722) | 35%
|
| Everton | 1981-1998 | Neville Southall (750) | 35%
|
| Chelsea | 1962-1980 | Ron Harris (795) | 30%
|
| Liverpool | 1960-1978 | Ian Callaghan (857) | 25%
|
| West Ham United | 1967-1988 | Billy Bonds (799) | 15%
|
| Fulham | 1952-1970 | Johnny Haynes (658) | 15%
|
| Tottenham Hotspur | 1969-1986 | Steve Perryman (854) | 15%
|
| Manchester City | 1959-1976 | Alan Oakes (676) | 10%
|
| Brighton and Hove Albion | 1922-1936 | Ernie Wilson (566) | 10%
|
| AFC Bournemouth | 1992-2007, 2009-2013 | Steve Fletcher (628) | 10%
|
| Aston Villa | 1961-1975 | Charlie Aitken (660) | 5%
|
| Crystal Palace | 1973-1988 | Jim Cannon (660) | 5%
|
| Nottingham Forest | 1951-1969 | Bob McKinlay (692) | 0%
|
| Luton Town | 1946-1964 | Bob Morton (562) | 0%
|
| Wolverhampton Wanderers | 1968-1982 | Derek Parkin (609) | 0%
|
| Burnley | 1907-1929 | Jerry Dawson (569) | 0%
|
| Newcastle United | 1904-1922 | Jimmy Lawrence (496) | 0%
|
| Sheffield United | 1945-1966 | Joe Shaw (713) | 0%
|
| Brentford | 1949-1964 | Ken Coote (559) | 0%
|