| Clue | Villain | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Has one cut for every Victim. | Zsasz | 76%
|
| Australian member of Suicide Squad | Captain Boomerang | 65%
|
| Always on time | Clock King | 65%
|
| Obsessed with Greek Mythology | Maxie Zeus | 59%
|
| Commits crimes with his puppet | Ventriloquist | 59%
|
| Able to communicate with rats | Ratcatcher | 57%
|
| Giant Gorilla | Gorilla Grodd | 56%
|
| Uses a hang glider to fly around | Kite-Man | 50%
|
| Teenage political activist | Anarky | 48%
|
| Ex-KGB assassin | KGBeast | 46%
|
| The Earth-Three version of Batman | Owlman | 43%
|
| Tried to put his grandmother back together again | Humpty Dumpty | 39%
|
| Very eggcelent and very eggxquisite | Egghead | 37%
|
| Former investor.. with razor sharp teeth. | Great White Shark | 37%
|
| Possessed by a witch | Enchantress | 35%
|
| Lester Buchinsky | Electrocutioner | 33%
|
| Mitchell Mayo | Condiment King | 31%
|
| Skilled toymaker | Dollmaker | 30%
|
| Eats the victim's faces while wearing pink | Flamingo | 30%
|
| A very slithery foe | Copperhead | 24%
|
| Heroin addcited arachnid | Black Spider | 20%
|
| Short plump identical twins | Tweedledee & Tweedledum | 19%
|
| Former artist that went blind can only see in vibrant colours. | Crazy Quilt | 13%
|
| He sees through his finger tips | Ten-eyed Man | 9%
|
| His polka dots turn into gadgets | Mr. Polka Dot | 6%
|