| # | Countries/Regions | Island | Area (km²) | Area (sq mi) | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Denmark (Greenland) | Greenland | 2,130,800 | 822,706 | 100%
|
| 2 | Canada | Baffin Island | 507,451 | 195,928 | 88%
|
| 4 | Canada | Ellesmere Island | 196,236 | 75,767 | 65%
|
| 5 | Canada | Newfoundland | 108,860 | 42,031 | 65%
|
| 3 | Canada | Victoria Island | 217,291 | 83,897 | 65%
|
| 6 | Canada | Banks Island | 70,028 | 27,038 | 35%
|
| 7 | Canada | Devon Island | 55,247 | 21,331 | 18%
|
| 10 | Canada | Southampton | 41,214 | 15,913 | 18%
|
| 8 | Canada | Axel Heiberg | 43,178 | 16,671 | 12%
|
| 9 | Canada | Melville | 42,149 | 16,274 | 12%
|