| # | Island | Area (km²) | Area (sq mi) | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Cuba | 104,553 | 40,368 | 100%
|
| 3 | Jamaica | 10,911 | 4,213 | 97%
|
| 2 | Hispaniola | 76,192 | 29,418 | 86%
|
| 4 | Puerto Rico | 8,870 | 3,425 | 83%
|
| 5 | Trinidad | 4,827 | 1,864 | 83%
|
| 10 | Grand Bahama Island | 1,373 | 530 | 48%
|
| 7 | Isla de la Juventud | 2,237 | 864 | 24%
|
| 6 | North Andros Island | 3,439 | 1,328 | 24%
|
| 9 | South Andros Island | 1,447 | 559 | 21%
|
| 8 | Great Inagua Island | 1,543 | 596 | 14%
|