| # | Countries/Regions | Island | Area (km²) | Area (sq mi) | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3 | Republic of Ireland, United Kingdom (Northern Ireland) | Ireland | 84,421 | 32,595 | 100%
|
| 2 | Iceland | Iceland | 101,826 | 39,315 | 98%
|
| 7 | Italy | Sicily | 25,662 | 9,908 | 93%
|
| 1 | United Kingdom (England, Scotland, Wales) | Great Britain | 229,848 | 88,745 | 91%
|
| 10 | France | Corsica | 8,741 | 3,351 | 89%
|
| 8 | Italy | Sardinia | 23,949 | 9,247 | 84%
|
| 5 | Norway (Svalbard) | Spitsbergen | 37,673 | 14,546 | 27%
|
| 4 | Russia (Novaya Zemlya) | Severny Island | 47,079 | 18,177 | 11%
|
| 6 | Russia (Novaya Zemlya) | Yuzhny Island | 33,246 | 12,836 | 9%
|
| 9 | Norway (Svalbard) | Nordaustlandet | 14,443 | 5,576 | 5%
|