| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Smaug | Dragons | 100%
|
| Boromir | Humans | 98%
|
| Azog the Defiler | Orcs | 98%
|
| Samwise Gamgee | Hobbits | 97%
|
| Glòin | Dwarves | 96%
|
| Thranduil | Elves | 94%
|
| Tom, Bert, and William | Trolls | 93%
|
| Treebeard | Ents | 92%
|
| Shadowfax | Horses | 92%
|
| The Witch King of Angmar | Nâzgul | 88%
|
| Shelob | Spiders | 87%
|
| Durin's Bane | Balrogs | 84%
|
| Gwaihir the Windlord | Eagles | 82%
|
| Ugl'k | Uruk-Hai | 80%
|
| Large wolves | Wargs | 75%
|
| Radagast the Brown | Maiar | 61%
|
| Enormous creatures used by Sauron's army in the Siege of Minas Tirith | Mûmakil | 56%
|
| Ulmo | Valar | 56%
|
| Huge mountain creatures who throw rocks | Giants | 50%
|
| Beorn | Skin-Changers | 50%
|
| Sea monster who lives outside the mines of Moria | The Watcher in the Water | 49%
|
| Large winged animals used by Sauron's black riders | Fell Beasts | 47%
|
| Large tunneling creatures | Wereworms | 43%
|
| Draugluin | Werewolves | 35%
|
| Thuringwithal | Vampires | 29%
|
| Large crow-like minions of Morgoth | Crebain | 22%
|
| Advanced version of the race above created by Saruman | Olog-Hai | 22%
|
| Tevildo | Cats | 21%
|