| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Boring priest who visits annually | Father Paul Stone | 85%
|
| Who stole the old grey whistle? | Father Damien Lennon | 79%
|
| Craggy Island's promiscuous milkman | Pat Mustard | 76%
|
| TV presenter that visits when Mrs. Doyle wins a peotry competition | Eoin McLove | 73%
|
| Nun who helps Ted and Dougal keep their lentern vows | Sister Assumpta | 65%
|
| Favourite to win the 'King of the Sheep' competition | Chris | 61%
|
| Former BBC presenter who judges the 'All Priests Stars in Their Eyes Lookalike Competition' | Henry Sellers | 55%
|
| Priest that replaces Father Jack when he is taken to St. Clabbert's | Father Fintan Stack | 52%
|
| 'One Foot in the Grave' actor haunted by his catchphrase | Richard Wilson | 50%
|
| Bishop Brennan's assistant and "the most sarcastic priest in Ireland" | Father Jessup | 45%
|
| Which priest tries to take Ted to America? | Father Buzz Cagney | 29%
|
| Parish priest for St. Luke's church | Father Noel Furlong | 27%
|
| Italian priest who scores first in the 'All-Priests five-a-side Over-75's Indoor Challenge Football Match' | Father Romeo Sensini | 26%
|
| The priest Ted asks to DJ at the raffle (aka 'the spinmaster') | Father Billy O'Dwyer | 23%
|
| Winner of the 'Lovely Girls' competition | Imelda | 23%
|