| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| C | Cabaret | Call Me Madam | Camelot | +54 | 89%
|
| H | Hadestown | Hair: The Musical | Hairspray | +32 | 81%
|
| L | La Cage Aux Folles | Lady Day at Emerson's Bar and Grill | +36 | 80%
|
| M | Mame | Mamma Mia | Man of La Mancha | +34 | 75%
|
| A | Addams Family, The | After Midnight | Aida | +52 | 74%
|
| W | Waitress | War Paint | Wedding Singer, The | +21 | 74%
|
| S | Saturday Night Fever | Scandalous | Scarlet Pimpernel, The | +50 | 71%
|
| B | Babes in Arms | Baby It's You | Bandstand, The | +64 | 65%
|
| P | Pacific Overtures | Paint Your Wagon | Pajama Game, The | +24 | 64%
|
| O | Of Thee I Sing | Oh! Calcutta! | Oklahoma! | +23 | 53%
|
| G | Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder, A | Gentlemen Prefer Blondes | +31 | 52%
|
| F | Fade Out - Fade In | Falsettos | A Family Affair | +30 | 50%
|
| R | Ragtime | Rain: A Tribute to the Beatles | Redhead | +26 | 45%
|
| D | Dames at Sea | Damn Yankees | Dear Evan Hansen | +30 | 39%
|
| J | Jekyll and Hyde | Jersey Boys | Jesus Christ Superstar | +13 | 34%
|
| K | Kean | Kelly | King David | +9 | 32%
|
| E | Earl and the Girl, The | Earl Carroll Vanities of 1931 |Earl of Ruston | +14 | 30%
|
| I | I Can Get It for You Wholesale | I Do! I Do! | I Love My Wife | +11 | 25%
|
| N | Natasha, Pierre and the Great Comet of 1812 | Newsies | +11 | 24%
|
| T | Taboo | Tarzan | Thirteen: The Musical | +24 | 21%
|
| X | Xanadu | 19%
|
| U | Urban Cowboy | Urinetown: The Musical | The Utter Glory of Morrissey Hall | 11%
|
| V | Very Good, Eddie | Very Warm for May | Via Galactica | +3 | 7%
|
| Y | You Said It | You're a Good Man Charlie Brown | Young Frankenstein | 5%
|
| Z | Zorba | 4%
|
| Q | Queen O' Hearts | Quilters | 2%
|