| Gang-Role | Birthdate | Nationality | Descent | Death date | Place of death | Fate | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gunman | 1863 | American | None | 1899 | Roanoke Ridge | Tuberculosis | Arthur Morgan | 97%
|
| Gunman | 1873 | American | Scottish | 1911 | Beecher's Hope | Shot & killed | John Marston, Sr. | 93%
|
| Gunman | Uncertain | American | NativeAmerican | Alive | - | Likely left for Canada | Charles Smith | 90%
|
| Gang leader | 1855 | American | Dutch, British | 1911 | West Elizabeth | Suicide | Dutch van der Linde | 90%
|
| Outlaw | 1895 | American | Scottish | Alive | - | Uncertain | John "Jack" Marston Jr. | 88%
|
| Gunwoman | Uncertain | American | None | Alive | - | Likely left for South America | Sadie Adler | 86%
|
| Thief | 1877 | American | None | 1914 | Beecher's Hope | Uncertain | Abigail Marston Roberts | 85%
|
| Gunman | Uncertain | Irish | None | 1899 | Rhodes | Shot & killed | Sean MacGuire | 85%
|
| Gunman | Uncertain | Mexican | None | 1911 | Nuevo Paraíso/in America | Shot & killed /executed (player's choice) | Javier Escuella | 83%
|
| Handmaid | Uncertain | American | None | 1899 | Roanoke Ridge | Shot & killed | Susan Grimshaw | 83%
|
| Gunman | 1860 | American | None | 1907 | Mount Hagen | Shot & killed | Micah Bell III | 82%
|
| Handmaid | Uncertain | American | None | Alive | - | Resides in St. Denis | Tilly Pierre Jackson | 82%
|
| Conman | 1844 | American | None | 1899 | St. Denis | Shot & killed | Hosea Matthews | 81%
|
| Gunman | 1880 | American | None | 1899 | St. Denis | Shot & killed | Leonard "Lenny" Summers | 79%
|
| Gunman | 1866 | American | None | 1911 | Nuevo Paraíso | Shot & killed | Marion ''Bill'' Williamson | 79%
|
| Gunwoman | Uncertain | American | None | Uncertain | - | Likely death from alcoholism | Karen Jones | 77%
|
| Thief | Uncertain | American | None | Alive | - | Famous novelist | Mary-Beth Gaskill | 77%
|
| Handmaid | Uncertain | Irish | None | 1899 | Roanoke Ridge | Shot & killed | Molly O'Shea | 77%
|
| Stable Boy | 1860 | American | Irish | 1899 | Shady Belle | Decapitated | Kieran Duffy | 76%
|
| Chef | Uncertain | American | None | Alive | - | Resides in Rhodes | Simon Pearson | 76%
|
| Thief | 1849 | American | None | 1911 | Beecher's Hope | Shot & killed | Uncle | 75%
|
| Conman | 1846 | British | None | Alive | - | Likely returned to his family | Josiah Trelawny | 69%
|
| Loanshark | 1846 | Austrian | None | Uncertain | Uncertain | Killed in custody | Leopold Strauss | 68%
|
| Priest | Uncertain | American | None | Alive | - | Left for New York | Orville Swanson | 68%
|
| Handmaid | Uncertain | American | Likely Scottish | 1899 | Spider Gorge | Succumbed to her injuries | Jenny Kirk | 60%
|
| Stray dog | Uncertain | Dog | None | 1899 (disappeared) | Roanoke Ridge | Likely killed by Micah | Cain | 58%
|
| Gunman | Uncertain | American | LikelyScottish | 1899 | Colter | Shot & killed | Davey Callander | 53%
|
| Gunman | Uncertain | American | Likely Scottish | 1899 | Uncertain | Killed in custody | Mac Callander | 53%
|
| Gunman | Uncertain | American | None | 1907 | Strawberry | Hanged/Shot (player's choice) | Cleet | 47%
|
| Gunman | Uncertain | American | None | 1907 | Mount Hagen | Shot & killed | Joe | 45%
|
| Handmaid | Uncertain | Uncertain | None | prior to 1899 | Uncertain | Killed by Colm O'Driscoll | Annabelle | 41%
|
| Handmaid | Uncertain | American | None | between 1883 and 1899 | Uncertain | Uncertain | Bessie Matthews | 18%
|
| Stray dog | Uncertain | Dog | None | 1898 | Montana | Salmon poisoning disease | Copper | 14%
|