| Occupation | Affiliation | Rank | Nationality | Death
date | Place of death | Fate | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Detective | Pinkerton National Detective Agency | High-ranked | American | 1899 | Van Horn | Shot & killed | Andrew Milton | 92%
|
| Outlaw | O'Driscoll Boys | Gang leader | Irish-American | 1899 | St. Denis | Hanged | Colm O'Driscoll | 88%
|
| Outlaw | Dutch's gang | Gang leader | American | 1911 | West Elizabeth | Suicide | Dutch van der Linde | 87%
|
| Businessman | Saint Denis Mob | Mob leader | Italian | 1899 | Bayou | Drowning | Angelo Bronte | 83%
|
| Detective | Pinkerton National Detective Agency | Senior agent | American | 1914 | New Austin | Shot & killed | Edgar Ross | 83%
|
| Officer | Gray family | Sheriff | American | 1899 | Rhodes | Shot & killed | Leigh Gray | 80%
|
| Outlaw | Williamson gang | Gang leader | American | 1911 | Nuevo Paraíso | Shot & killed | Marion ''Bill'' Williamson | 79%
|
| Businesswoman | Braithwaite Manor | Matriarch | American | 1899 | Lemoyne | Immolation | Catherine Braithwaite | 78%
|
| Outlaw | Mexican Army | - | Mexican | 1911 | Nuevo Paraíso / in America | Shot & killed /executed (player's choice) | Javier Escuella | 78%
|
| Outlaw | van der Linde gang, Pinkertons | - | American | 1907 | Mount Hagen | Shot & killed | Micah Bell III | 77%
|
| Industrialist | Southern and Eastern Railway | - | American | 1899 | Annesburg | Shot & killed | Leviticus Cornwall | 71%
|
| Businessman | Gray family | Patriarch | American | 1899 | Caliga Hall | Suicide | Tavish Gray | 70%
|
| Enforcer | Cuban Military | Colonel | Cuban | 1899 | Guarma | Shot & killed | Alberto Fussar | 68%
|
| Outlaw | Foreman Brothers | Gang leader | American | Alive / 1899 | Lemoyne | Stabbed (Player's choice) | Anthony Foreman | 55%
|
| Soldier | U.S. Military | Colonel | American | 1899 | New Hanover | Shot & killed | Henry Favours | 38%
|
| Enforcer | Cuban Military | High- ranked | American | 1899 | Guarma | Shot & killed | Levi Simon | 37%
|
| Officer | Gray family | Deputy | American | 1899 | Rhodes | Shot & killed | Archibald MacGregor | 33%
|
| Governor | Mexican Army | Colonel | Mexican | 1911 | Nuevo Paraíso | Shot & killed | Agustin Allende | 30%
|
| Soldier | Mexican Army | Captain | Mexican | 1911 | Nuevo Paraíso | Shot & killed | Vincente de Santa | 29%
|
| Federal agent | Bureau of Investigation | Protegé | American | Alive | - | Uncertain | Archer Fordham | 19%
|
| Soldier | Mexican Army | Captain | Mexican | 1911 | Nuevo Paraíso | Shot & killed | Espinoza | 11%
|
| Outlaw | Williamson gang | second-in-command | American | 1911 | Tumbleweed | Shot & killed | Norman Deek | 11%
|
| Detective | Pinkerton National Detective Agency | Low-ranked | American | Alive / 1899 | Shady Belle | Shot & killed (Player's choice) | Mr. Johns | 8%
|
| Detective | Pinkerton National Detective Agency | Low-ranked | American | Alive / 1899 | Shady Belle | Shot & killed (Player's choice) | Mr. Bunter | 6%
|
| Detective | Pinkerton National Detective Agency | Low-ranked | American | Alive / 1899 | Shady Belle | Shot & killed (Player's choice) | Mr. Orly | 6%
|