| Team | Year | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| HOU | 2004 | Andre Johnson | 88%
|
| GBP | 1942 | Don Hutson | 69%
|
| MIA | 1983 | Mark Duper | 69%
|
| SEA | 1978 | Steve Largent | 69%
|
| JAX | 1996 | Keenan McCardell | 56%
|
| NEP | 1979 | Harold Jackson | 50%
|
| DEN | 1960 | Lionel Taylor | 50%
|
| KAN | 1966 | Otis Taylor | 50%
|
| CIN | 1981 | Cris Collinsworth | 44%
|
| IND | 1960 | Raymond Berry | 44%
|
| NYJ | 1960 | Don Maynard | 38%
|
| CLE | 1968 | Paul Warfield | 31%
|
| CHI | 1954 | Harlon Hill | 25%
|
| WAS | 1962 | Bobby Mitchell | 19%
|
| NOS | 1969 | Danny Abramowicz | 13%
|
| BAL | 1996 | Derrick Alexander | 13%
|
| TBB | 1981 | Kevin House | 13%
|
| CAR | 1995 | Mark Carrier | 13%
|
| PHI | 1953 | Pete Pihos | 13%
|
| LVR | 1963 | Art Powell | 6%
|
| TEN | 1960 | Bill Groman | 6%
|
| DET | 1949 | Bob Mann | 6%
|
| PIT | 1961 | Buddy Dial | 6%
|
| BUF | 1964 | Elbert Dubenion | 6%
|
| DAL | 1962 | Frank Clarke | 6%
|
| LAR | 1945 | Jim Benton | 6%
|
| SFF | 1961 | R.C. Owens | 6%
|
| ARI | 1962 | Sonny Randle | 6%
|
| LAC | 1961 | Dave Kocourek | 0%
|
| NYG | 1961 | Del Shofner | 0%
|
| MIN | 1972 | John Gilliam | 0%
|
| ATL | 1979 | Wally Francis | 0%
|