| Age | Pos | School | Heisman | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 23 | QB | Alabama | Bryce Young | 100%
|
| 57 | QB | BYU | Ty Detmer | 100%
|
| 29 | QB | Oklahoma | Baker Mayfield | 80%
|
| 56 | RB | Oklahoma State | Barry Sanders | 80%
|
| 62 | RB | Auburn | Bo Jackson | 80%
|
| 47* | RB | Minnesota | Bruce Smith | 80%
|
| 23 | QB | USC | Caleb Williams | 80%
|
| 35 | QB | Auburn | Cam Newton | 80%
|
| 64* | RB | USC | Charles White | 80%
|
| 30 | RB | Alabama | Derrick Henry | 80%
|
| 26 | WR | Alabama | Devonta Smith | 80%
|
| 23* | RB | Syracuse | Ernie Davis | 80%
|
| 80* | RB | Army | Glenn Davis | 80%
|
| 30 | QB | Florida State | Jameis Winston | 80%
|
| 44 | QB | Oklahoma | Jason White | 80%
|
| 88* | RB | Chicago | Jay Berwanger | 80%
|
| 24 | QB | LSU | Jayden Daniels | 80%
|
| 28 | QB | LSU | Joe Burrow | 80%
|
| 27 | QB | Oklahoma | Kyler Murray | 80%
|
| 27 | QB | Louisville | Lamar Jackson | 80%
|
| 31 | QB | Oregon | Marcus Mariota | 80%
|
| 76* | RB | USC | O.J. Simpson | 80%
|
| 47 | RB | Texas | Ricky Williams | 80%
|
| 79 | QB | Florida | Steve Spurrier | 80%
|
| 37 | QB | Florida | Tim Tebow | 80%
|
| 21 | CB/WR | Colorado | Travis Hunter | 80%
|
| 40 | QB | Ohio State | Troy Smith | 80%
|
| 55* | FB | Wisconsin | Alan Ameche | 60%
|
| 56 | QB | Houston | Andre Ware | 60%
|
| 70 | RB | Ohio State | Archie Griffin | 60%
|
| 80* | RB | LSU | Billy Cannon | 60%
|
| 69 | RB | Oklahoma | Billy Sims | 60%
|
| 44 | QB | USC | Carson Palmer | 60%
|
| 50 | QB | Florida | Danny Wuerffel | 60%
|
| 71* | RB | SMU | Doak Walker | 60%
|
| 69 | RB | Texas | Earl Campbell | 60%
|
| 66 | RB | South Carolina | George Rogers | 60%
|
| 62 | RB | Georgia | Herschel Walker | 60%
|
| 77 | QB | Stanford | Jim Plunkett | 60%
|
| 72 | RB | Penn State | John Cappelletti | 60%
|
| 32 | QB | Texas A&M | Johnny Manziel | 60%
|
| 73 | WR | Nebraska | Johnny Rodgers | 60%
|
| 64 | RB | USC | Marcus Allen | 60%
|
| 41 | QB | USC | Matt Leinart | 60%
|
| 24* | RB | Iowa | Nile Kinnick | 60%
|
| 42* | RB | Colorado | Rashaan Salaam | 60%
|
| 39 | RB | USC | Reggie Bush | 60%
|
| 34 | QB | Baylor | Robert Griffin III | 60%
|
| 82 | QB | Navy | Roger Staubach | 60%
|
| 37 | QB | Oklahoma | Sam Bradford | 60%
|
| 61 | QB | Miami | Vinny Testaverde | 60%
|
| 48 | CB | Michigan | Charles Woodson | 40%
|
| 54 | QB | Florida State | Charlie Ward | 40%
|
| 52 | QB | Florida State | Chris Weinke | 40%
|
| 54 | WR | Michigan | Desmond Howard | 40%
|
| 84* | RB | Army | Doc Blanchard | 40%
|
| 62 | RB | Boston College | Doug Flutie | 40%
|
| 51 | RB | Ohio State | Eddie George | 40%
|
| 46 | QB | Nebraska | Eric Crouch | 40%
|
| 54 | QB | Miami | Gino Torretta | 40%
|
| 85* | RB | Ohio State | Howard Cassady | 40%
|
| 79* | RB | Texas A&M | John David Crow | 40%
|
| 98* | QB | Notre Dame | Johnny Lujack | 40%
|
| 34 | RB | Alabama | Mark Ingram | 40%
|
| 63 | RB | Nebraska | Mike Rozier | 40%
|
| 69* | QB | Auburn | Pat Sullivan | 40%
|
| 84* | QB | Notre Dame | Paul Hornung | 40%
|
| 46 | RB | Wisconsin | Ron Dayne | 40%
|
| 83 | QB | Oregon State | Terry Baker | 40%
|
| 58 | WR | Notre Dame | Tim Brown | 40%
|
| 70* | RB | Michigan | Tom Harmon | 40%
|
| 70 | RB | Pittsburgh | Tony Dorsett | 40%
|
| 76* | RB | Yale | Clint Frank | 20%
|
| 82* | RB | Princeton | Dick Kazmaier | 20%
|
| 70* | RB | Georgia | Frank Sinkwich | 20%
|
| 78 | QB | UCLA | Gary Beban | 20%
|
| 81* | RB | Navy | Joe Bellino | 20%
|
| 85* | END | Yale | Larry Kelley | 20%
|
| 73* | END | Notre Dame | Leon Hart | 20%
|
| 80 | RB | USC | Mike Garrett | 20%
|
| 77 | FB | Oklahoma | Steve Owens | 20%
|
| 78* | QB | Notre Dame | Angelo Bertelli | 0%
|
| 70* | RB | Oklahoma | Billy Vessels | 0%
|
| 60* | QB | TCU | Davey O'Brien | 0%
|
| 81 | QB | Notre Dame | John Huarte | 0%
|
| 83* | RB | Notre Dame | Johnny Lattner | 0%
|
| 74* | RB | Ohio State | Les Horvath | 0%
|
| 86 | RB | Army | Pete Dawkins | 0%
|
| 66* | RB | Ohio State | Vic Janowicz | 0%
|