| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Liver Cancer | Walter Payton | 69%
|
| Unkown | Jim Taylor | 59%
|
| Murdered | Sean Taylor | 59%
|
| Pulmonary embolism | Derrick Thomas | 50%
|
| Arrhythmia | Reggie White | 41%
|
| Heart Attack | Johnny Unitas | 38%
|
| Murdered | Steve McNair | 34%
|
| Suicide | Aaron Hernandez | 31%
|
| Stroke | Bart Starr | 31%
|
| Suicide | Junior Seau | 31%
|
| Natural Causes | Deacon Jones | 28%
|
| Heart Attack | Rosey Brown | 28%
|
| Kidney Failure | Sammy Baugh | 28%
|
| Heart Attack | Kevin Greene | 25%
|
| Heart Attack | Mike Webster | 25%
|
| Dementia | Gale Sayers | 22%
|
| Aneurysm | Otto Graham | 22%
|
| Cancer | Larry Wilson | 19%
|
| Cardiac Arrest | Bobby Layne | 16%
|
| Heart Attack | Dick Lane | 16%
|
| Undisclosed Illness | Don Hutson | 16%
|
| Dementia | Paul Hornung | 16%
|
| Natural Causes | Y.A. Tittle | 16%
|
| Short Illness | George Blanda | 13%
|
| Colon Cancer | Ken Stabler | 13%
|
| Heart Attack | Norm Van Brocklin | 13%
|
| Cancer | Sid Luckman | 13%
|
| Lou Gehrig's disease | Dwight Clark | 9%
|
| Pancreatic Cancer | Gene Upshaw | 9%
|
| Congestive heart failure/chronic kidney disease | Jim Parker | 9%
|
| Pneumonia | Red Grange | 9%
|
| Pneumonia | Steve Van Buren | 9%
|
| Natural Causes | Willie Davis | 9%
|
| Natural Causes | Bronko Nagurski | 6%
|
| Pneumonia | Gino Marchetti | 6%
|
| Dementia | John Mackey | 6%
|
| Stroke | Lee Roy Selmon | 6%
|
| Natural Causes | Sam Huff | 6%
|
| Kidney Disease | Alex Karras | 3%
|
| Dementia | Bobby Dillon | 3%
|
| Lung Cancer | Buck Buchanan | 3%
|
| Natural Causes | Doug Atkins | 3%
|
| Parkinson's | Forrest Gregg | 3%
|
| Heart Attack | Ray Nitschke | 3%
|
| Heart Attack | Curly Lambeau | 0%
|
| Unkown | Herb Adderley | 0%
|
| Heart Attack | Jack Tatum | 0%
|
| Heart Attack | Jim Thorpe | 0%
|
| Kidney Failure | L.C. Greenwood | 0%
|
| Dementia | Nick Buoniconti | 0%
|