| Character Name | Description | Episode | Actor | Bonus Hint | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bart "Zero" Liquori | An arcade owner with a striking friend | D.P.O. | Jack Black | Comedian, voice actor, Tenacious D member | 72%
|
| Patrick Crump | A man that must desperately travel west | Drive | Bryan Cranston | Would famously work again with episode writer Vince Gilligan | 61%
|
| Jay "Boom" DeBoom | A redshirt jock | Syzygy | Ryan Reynolds | Vancouver native, ex-husband of Scarlett Johansson | 56%
|
| Kim Hsin | A young woman with leukemia | Hell Money | Lucy Liu | Has been an angel, a viper, a cottonmouth, a lawyer, and a watson | 50%
|
| Sheriff Hartwell | Sheriff of Chaney, TX. May or may not have buck teeth. | Bad Blood | Luke Wilson | Starred in Wes Anderson's Bottle Rocket (1996) with brother and fellow actor Owen | 50%
|
| Betty | Ed Jerse's tattoo | Never Again | Jodie Foster | Two time Oscar winner. A man tried to assassinate Ronald Reagan for her. | 44%
|
| Unnamed child | A deceased yet "saved" child | (most likely) Closure | Jennette McCurdy | Author of the bestselling "I'm Glad My Mom Died" | 39%
|
| Richie Lupone | A sickly boy | The Goldberg Variation | Shia LaBeouf | Controversial former Disney Channel kid. Part of the Transformers and Indiana Jones franchises | 39%
|
| Téa Leoni | Plays a fictionalized version of Scully | Hollywood A.D. | Téa Leoni | Was married to the episode's director | 39%
|
| David "Winky" Winkle | A "Jackass" style teen daredevil | Lord of the Flies | Aaron Paul | Plays the above's partner-in-crime in said Vince Gilligan show | 33%
|
| Lyda | A woman who died in 1917 | How the Ghosts Stole Christmas | Lily Tomlin | Starred in 9 to 5 (1980) with Dolly Parton and frequent collaborator Jane Fonda. Voiced Ms. Frizzle. | 33%
|
| Nurse | Nurse | Millenium | Octavia Spencer | Oscar nominated and (one-time winner) for The Help, Hidden Figures, and The Shape of Water | 33%
|
| Man in Black 1 | CLASSIFIED | Jose Chung's From Outer Space | Jesse Ventura | Wrestler, Vietnam veteran, Minnesota governor. Attempted to unionize the WWF. | 28%
|
| Man in Black 2 | CLASSIFIED | Jose Chung's From Outer Space | Alex Trebek | Famous game show host. Who is... | 22%
|
| Luther Lee Boggs | A serial killer who claims to have psychic abilities | Beyond the Sea | Brad Dourif | Known for playing a killer doll, an evil advisor, and a psych ward patient | 22%
|
| Wayne Weinsider | A husband who just wants a normal child | Terms of Endearment | Bruce Campbell | Horror icon known for playing Ash Williams | 22%
|
| Emil | A stoner teen | Deep Throat | Seth Green | Co-creator of Robot Chicken | 22%
|
| Dr. Chester Ray Banton | A dark matter scientist with a killer shadow | Soft Light | Tony Shalhoub | Winner of 4 primetime Emmys, three of which were for the character Adrian Monk | 22%
|
| Detective Glen Chao | A SFPD detective | Hell Money | BD Wong | Voice of Li Shang in Mulan (1998) | 17%
|
| Cesar Ocampo | A man seeking revenge | Redrum | Danny Trejo | Frequent collaborator of filmmaker and second cousin Robert Rodriguez. | 11%
|
| Second Officer | Background character | Surekill | James Franco | Played James Dean, Tommy Wiseau, and Harry Osborn. Payed a $2.2 million sexual misconduct settlement | 11%
|
| Tad O'Malley | Conspiracy theorist with a TV show | My Struggle | Joel McHale | "Community" graduate | 11%
|
| Submarine Crew Member (extra) | A doomed WWII sailor. | Piper Maru | Michael Bublé | "Santa Buddy" singer. Uncredited as he was fired for stealing a hot dog on the X-Files set. | 11%
|
| Darryl Weaver | A chain smoker and test subject | Brand X | Tobin Bell | Best known for playing serial killer John Kramer who wants people to live their lives to the fullest | 11%
|
| Augustus Cole | A Vietnam vet with strange powers | Sleepless | Tony Todd | Say his most famous character's name five times (not three!) and he appears | 11%
|
| Jeff Glaser | A "tech head" helping local police | Detour | Anthony Rapp | Originated the role of Mark Cohen in "Rent". The first of over a dozen individuals who accused Kevin Spacey of misconduct. | 6%
|
| Brad Follmer | FBI Assistant Director who has a history with Monica Reyes | Nothing Important Happened Today | Cary Elwes | Known for his fantasy film roles and playing one of the above's first victims | 6%
|
| The Hard Faced Man | A Chinatown power player | Hell Money | James Hong | Working since the 1950s, he has over 600 screen credits (including voicing the above's adopted father) | 6%
|
| Anne Lokensgard | A high school principal with a secret | Lord of the Flies | Jane Lynch | Later got a promotion to cheer coach | 6%
|
| Shannon McMahon | A strangely water adept woman | Nothing Important Happened Today | Lucy Lawless | Former warrior princess | 6%
|
| Opponent | A nameless wrestler | Fight Club | Rob Van Dam | One of only two wrestler to have won the WWE, ECW & TNA Championships | 0%
|