| Year | Debut Team | Player | WAR | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2016 | New York Yankees | Aaron Judge | 45.7 | 95%
|
| 2018 | Los Angeles Angels | Shohei Ohtani | 37.7 | 91%
|
| 2011 | Los Angeles Angels | Mike Trout | 86.2 | 86%
|
| 2019 | San Diego Padres | Fernando Tatis Jr. | 20.7 | 82%
|
| 2022 | Seattle Mariners | Julio Rodriguez | 12.5 | 77%
|
| 2005 | Detroit Tigers | Justin Verlander | 81.7 | 77%
|
| 2008 | Los Angeles Dodgers | Clayton Kershaw | 79.7 | 73%
|
| 2015 | Cleveland Guardians | Francisco Lindor | 44.3 | 73%
|
| 2010 | Atlanta Braves | Freddie Freeman | 58.3 | 73%
|
| 2012 | Baltimore Orioles | Manny Machado | 55.2 | 73%
|
| 2009 | Pittsburgh Pirates | Andrew McCutchen | 49.1 | 68%
|
| 2003 | Florida Marlins | Miguel Cabrera | 67.1 | 68%
|
| 2014 | Boston Red Sox | Mookie Betts | 68.5 | 68%
|
| 2001 | St. Louis Cardinals | Albert Pujols | 101.4 | 64%
|
| 2007 | Cincinnati Reds | Joey Votto | 64.5 | 64%
|
| 2013 | Colorado Rockies | Nolan Arenado | 54.1 | 59%
|
| 2023 | New York Yankees | Anthony Volpe | 6.1 | 55%
|
| 2024 | Chicago Cubs | Shota Imanaga | 2.1 | 55%
|
| 2004 | Kansas City Royals | Zack Greinke | 77.5 | 32%
|
| 2002 | Cleveland Guardians | Cliff Lee | 43.2 | 27%
|
| 2017 | Oakland Athletics | Matt Chapman | 33.9 | 27%
|
| 2006 | Philadelphia Phillies | Cole Hamels | 59.0 | 23%
|
| 2000 | Chicago White Sox | Mark Buehrle | 59.1 | 18%
|
| 2021 | San Diego Padres | Ha-Seong Kim | 14.3 | 14%
|
| 2020 | New York Mets | Andres Gimenez | 16.1 | 5%
|