| Mets | % Correct | |
|---|---|---|
| Rookie of the Year | Tom Seaver | Jon Matlack | Darryl Strawberry | Dwight Gooden | Jacob deGrom | Pete Alonso | 94%
|
| Hall of Fame | Roberto Alomar | Randy Johnson | 76%
|
| Gold Glove | Charles Johnson | Luis Castillo | Derrek Lee | Mike Lowell | Mark Buehrle | Christian Yelich | Dee Gordon | Marcell Ozuna | 73%
|
| Hall of Fame | Yogi Berra | Nolan Ryan | Gil Hodges | Roberto Alomar | Eddie Murray | Warren Spahn | Willie Mays | Duke Snider | Richie Ashburn | Gary Carter | Rickey Henderson | Tom Glavine | Mike Piazza | Pedro Martinez | 70%
|
| Rookie of the Year | Corbin Carroll | 66%
|
| Hall of Fame | Tim Raines | Trevor Hoffman | Mike Piazza | Ivan Rodriguez | Andre Dawson | 63%
|
| Gold Glove | Steve Finley | Christian Walker | Gabriel Moreno | Orlando Hudson | Gerardo Parra | Paul Goldschmidt | AJ Pollock | Zack Greinke | 62%
|
| Gold Glove | Ron Darling | Keith Hernandez | Doug Flynn | Bud Harrelson | Rey Ordóñez | Robin Ventura | David Wright | Tommie Agee | Carlos Beltran | Juan Lagares | 58%
|
| Rookie of the Year | Dontrelle Willis | Hanley Ramirez | Chris Coghlan | Jose Fernandez | 39%
|