| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Location of place in the US that contains evidence of visitors from outer space. | Area 51 | 81%
|
| Ghost who appears in the mirror when her name is called out multiple times. | Bloody Mary | 81%
|
| A large, hairy, mythical creature that has an awful smell and high-pitched cry. | Bigfoot | 67%
|
| A creature that sucks the blood of domestic animals, especially goats. | Chupacabra | 67%
|
| Cloaked Hessian solder who was decapitated by a cannonball that rides a horse. | Headless Horseman | 59%
|
| A small child is bit by a spider. The spider bit swells, bursts, and releases thousands of baby spiders. | The Spider Bite | 19%
|
| Small human-like creature with fat, bulging heads that emerge from hiding places to attack people. | Melon Heads | 11%
|
| White scaled, red eyed albino alligator that roamed sewers of New York City. | Sewer Alligator | 7%
|