| Hint | Team | League | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lost 4 Super Bowls in a row in the early 1990s. Kicked missed 1991 Super Bowl winning kick "Wide Right" | Bills | NFL | 88%
|
| Have had 41 difference starting quarterbacks since they reentered the leaguen in 1999. Have never made a Super Bowl. | Browns | NFL | 88%
|
| Won one Super Bowl in 1969, and had the infamous Butt Fumble | Jets | NFL | 83%
|
| Only won 1 championship with LeBron, lost 3 finals to the Warriors, have never made the Finals without LeBron, have a 4.73 winning percentage all time. | Cavaliers | NBA | 79%
|
| They have not one a Playoff Series since returning as a team in 2004, have not made the playoffs since 2016, drafted Kobe then traded him on Draft Night, and had the worst record in NBA history in their 2011-2012 season. | Hornets | NBA | 79%
|
| Have won two World Series since 1962, have an extremely high payroll, terrible collapses in 2007, and 2025. | Mets | MLB | 79%
|
| Have never made the World Series, had the best record in MLB history in 2001 and got eliminated in the ALCS. | Mariners | MLB | 71%
|
| Have made the playoffs once since 2007, were part of the supposedly rigged 2002 Western Conference Finals | Kings | NBA | 67%
|
| Have won 2 world series in over 100 years, very low payroll, in 2007 they had a swarm of midges enter their home field, and in 2025 have gotten two pitchers investigated for gambling. | Guardians | MLB | 54%
|
| Have won one playoff series since they became a team in 1997. | Blue Jackets | NHL | 42%
|