| Hint | MLB Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Over 4000 hits | Pete Rose | 87%
|
| Hit a bird with a pitch | Randy Johnson | 87%
|
| Have a home run and an interception | Deion Sanders | 79%
|
| Win a triple crown since 1970 | Miguel Cabrera | 74%
|
| Have a home run go off of his head | Jose Canseco | 68%
|
| Died in a boat crash | Jose Fernandez | 68%
|
| Two grand slams in one inning | Fernando Tatis | 55%
|
| Play for 14 teams | Edwin Jackson | 47%
|
| Steal home plate over 50 times | Ty Cobb | 45%
|
| To get killed by a pitch | Ray Chapman | 32%
|
| Under five feet | Eddie Gaedel | 24%
|
| Play in MLB and NBA | Danny Ainge | 21%
|
| Have no-hitters on back to back starts | Johnny Vander Meer | 21%
|
| To kill a batter with a pitch | Carl Mays | 16%
|
| Player with one eye | Drew Robinson | 16%
|
| With hits for two teams on the same day | Joel Youngblood | 13%
|
| Start two combined no-hitters in one season | Christian Javier | 5%
|
| Won an Olympic Figure Skating Medal | Eddie Alvarez | 5%
|
| Hit eight home runs in one game | Jay Clarke | 5%
|
| Play all nine positions in one game outside of the 1960's | Scott Sheldon | 3%
|